Discrepancy between Linf and Lmax estimates in ELEFAN_GA analysis using TropFishR: How to Resolve?

@all In the context of ELEFAN_GA analysis using TropFishR, "Linf" and "Lmax" are two important parameters estimated for length-based stock assessment models. "Linf" refers to the asymptotic length, which is the maximum length a fish of a certain species can reach under optimal conditions, while "Lmax" is the maximum observed length of the fish in the sample data.

When there is a discrepancy between the estimated "Linf" and "Lmax" values, it could indicate potential issues or challenges in the analysis. Here are some possible reasons for the discrepancy and steps to resolve them:

Sample bias: The discrepancy may arise if the sample data used for analysis does not represent the full length range of the fish species. If the sample is biased towards smaller individuals, the estimated "Lmax" could be lower than the true maximum length. To resolve this, try to collect more comprehensive and representative length data, especially including larger individuals.

Growth variability: In some fish populations, there can be substantial individual variation in growth rates. This can lead to differences between the estimated "Linf" and "Lmax." Using length-age data or other growth information might help improve the estimation accuracy and reduce the discrepancy.

Model assumptions: Check the assumptions made in the ELEFAN_GA analysis. Make sure that the assumptions regarding growth patterns, mortality rates, and recruitment are appropriate for the species under study. Adjusting or refining these assumptions may lead to better parameter estimates.

Data quality: Examine the data for errors, outliers, or inconsistencies that might affect the estimates. Ensure that the length measurements are accurate and appropriately recorded. Cleaning the data and removing any problematic records might help improve the results.

Model selection: Evaluate different length-based stock assessment models to see if one provides a better fit to the data and reduces the discrepancy between "Linf" and "Lmax." TropFishR offers various models, so exploring alternative model configurations might be beneficial.

Refine initial parameter values: The initial parameter values used in the analysis can impact the convergence and final estimates. Experiment with different starting values to see if it affects the discrepancy between "Linf" and "Lmax."

Seek expert advice: If the discrepancy persists after trying the above steps, it might be beneficial to consult with experts in stock assessment or use other statistical techniques to validate the results.

Remember that resolving the discrepancy between "Linf" and "Lmax" requires a comprehensive understanding of the fish species, data quality, and the assumptions made in the analysis. It might involve iterative adjustments and improvements to the analysis process.

How should impedance for carbon materials be?

How to compare two groups with only two measurements?

Enhanced Yellow Fluorescent Protein (Aequorea victoria) DNA sequence?

What kind of fluid could I use for a pitfall trap that also does not invalidate molecular testing?

What's the best way to measure growth rates in House sparrow chicks from day 2 to day 10?

Do we need to write protocol for a second study of a systematic review that has been registered and published?

How to increase a model accuracy ?

1. What is the impact of having different scales in a survey? and how can we solve this problem before and after data collection (Literature)?

What degree of missing data in a particular case/participant results in Expectation-Maximisation no longer working?

Do I need to do linear regression before running mediation analysis using PROCESS MACRO by Hayes ?

Sample dilution for quantitative analysis using ELISA?