I am interested in studying the interaction of outer mitochondrial membrane bound proteins by co-immunoprecipitation. Which would be the most suitable detergent for this study: Digitonin Vs CHAPS Vs Triton?
I have used Triton X-100 (1% and below) or Tween-20 (1% and below) for co-IP experiments with good success. I've not used CHAPS or digitonin so I can't really compare how they will affect results relative to triton. The use of a non-ionic detergent vs a zwitter ionic detergent depends on your particular system. In my experience, saponin-based detergents are generally used for permeability of membranes that will still leave the overall membrane structure intact (for IF staining, etc) or as a mild additive to minimize non-specific binding in immunoassays.
I recommend starting with a lysis and wash buffer that contains 1% TX-100, and adjusting the concentration or testing other detergents if you see contamination. It all depends on particular proteins you are trying to detect via co-IP.
You may also consider adding glycerol to your extraction buffer to improve protein stability.
Its a good option to start first with isolating mitochondria. Also certain membrane protein donot solubilize in non denaturing condition such as in 1% TX-100. You need to use some chaotropic agents along with detergent to solubilize all the protein irrespective whether it is transmembrane or membrane. But this will break all protein-protein interaction (PPI).
IP only with TX-100 mostly works out for Strong PPI and ones that are soluble in TX-100. You can check whether you protein is soluble in TX-100 or not.
This the protocol I used to study trasmembrane protein interaction in the nuclear envelope, some of the resistant proteins such as Intermediate filaments can be solubilized, but I crosslink all the proteins just before lysis.
1. Isolate mitochondria or take whole cell pellet
2. Add 7M UREA and 1% TX-100 (say 100-200ul) and incubate 20 mins on ice, or 5 times the size of the pellet, use Protease inhibitor in all the step. -- Lysate
3. Since such high concentration will degrade you antibody, if you directly do IP. Dilute the above mixture 7 or 8 times, so the concetration of TX-100 is less than 0.2% and urea is less than 1M. So your final volume of lysate after diluting will be 1.5 to 2.0 ml. With this volume you can do IP.