I only can attach on file per post

Dear Mohsen,

I don't know how Fuzzy AHP method you are using, but if the data collection is the traditional, you might build a Hierarchy first, then make a questionnaire.

If you put the Hierarchy here, I can help you. If you don't even have an hierarchy, Tell us more about the problem, and the criteria to evaluate the situation, and then I can try to help you in these points.

Thanks alot Henrique

I attached a Table of my criteria, i want to weighting the criterias with expert's opinions, and i want to use Chang's FAHP for this, now i need a questionnaire with paired comparisons...

Sorry because the time. I was in a trip. I will analyze your paper tomorrow and answer it.

Hi there,

In attachement, I am sending to you two files.

1st - a dot ahp file, from Expert Choice Program (a software that implements AHP procedures.

2nd - A word document with the questionnaire generated from ExpertChoice Program.

I hope I've helped you.

I only can attach on file per post

Wow, Thank you so much for your kindness, You've helped me really.

Thank you for your good discussion.

Could you also please help me to convert Likert scale to pairwise and after that doing AHP to weight my criteria? as the attachment.

Dear Reza,

You must buit the hiearchy first. Each part of hiearchy should have at maximum nine criterias.

Do you have the hiearchy?

Dear Henrique,

Yes. I made it, but my criteria are more than 9 (around 25) to make this pairwise questionnaire. So, I am in need of an alternative solution to weight my criteria.

Or if there is any way to convert the Likert Scale to Pairwise Scale.

Thank you

Dear Reza,

If it is not possible to divide the criteria in at least trhee groups in the hierarchy, I cannot see a way to solve it.

By the way, I don't know a way to convert Likert Scale to pairwise scale, and as far as I can understant, this is not possible.

What I strongly suggest you is to review you hierarchy, and have in mind that each son of goal should be at most 9 subcriteria.

AHP does not fit in problems that you must compare more than 9 criteria at the same time

Dear Henrique,

This is my questionnaire's link. I did not make the AHP format yet, because I am not sure that I able to weight this amount of criteria by AHP method.

Please have a look and give me your method to weight them.

Tq

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1s5DYusWFQZBGbLMbIxGE94qCfQC0Ov5O1WYd1iwH_Gc/viewform

Dear Reza,

In this format AHP cannot help you. The Likert answers do not fit in the AHP model.

If do you must podwering the items, you have do develop another questionnaire to ask it to your sample (or a specialists commitee). I suggest the last one.

Thank you for your comment. What is your idea about:

According to the marks that I will get from student , I'll be able to statistically arrange the criteria, and choose first 9 or 15 criteria for making the AHP questionnaire and asking some experts in the filed to do pairwise.

After that I'll find the weight of each criteria.

Is that a good way?

Thank u

Dear Reza,

Depends on the answers aggregation procedure you will use. If weighted mean, you will need the weight of each item, and then enter the AHP.

In That case, you MUST separe them in groups of at maximum 9 items, and them, you develop the questionnaire em submit it only for specialists.

You will have the mean from the students and the weights from specialistas (like professors). I think this is a good way to solve the problem.

Thank you.

Please have a look at this PDF, which is showing how to convert Ordinal to Pairwise Scale. (From page 9 ) Could you please see if its correct or not?

Thank you

Also Page 2 of this article ;

Dear Reza,

I didn't know this procedure. I read it carefully and after them, I cannot agree with them.

The pairwaise scale is a rational scale, and as well, the procedure for agreggation must be rational. We must use geometric mean instead of arithmetic mean.

Although measuring the same thing, the scale are not the same, and I think the procedures do not solve this problem. I do believe this procedures increase the rank reversal problem.

However, this procedure is new to me and demands attention. I'll take it to my research group and we'll discuss on it.

And as researcher on AHP, I suggest try to found it in a more mature journals or specifics conferences.

Really thanks for your comment, which is very useful. I'll do my best to find it in the mature journals, if any cases.

And appreciate your thinking about finding the way to solve it. May we could write a good article for the proposed finding.

Thank you

For sure we can.

Hi Mohsen,

Could you please share me the design of Fuzzy AHP Questionnaire for pairwise comparision ? Thanks a lot

Of course dear Doan, I'll send you.

Hi Mohsen,

Can you send me that questionnaire too? Mamnoon

Sure, dear Khubaib.

What is the difference between a normal AHP questionnaire and a Fuzzy AHP questionnaire?

I would like to also ask for AHP questionnaire, thank you.

My email: [email protected].

Thank you

Sure dear Katerina Drncova, it sent.

Hi Mohsen Mazaheri Asad can you send me the AHP questionnaire as well, thank you.

Myemail :[email protected]

Dear Mohsen,

Can you send me your design of Fuzzy AHP Questionnaire also, thank you from now.

[email protected]

I have published an article entitled "Designing Integrated Management Criteria of Creative Ideation Based on Fuzzy Delphi Analytical Hierarchy Process".

You can use this paper.

Link:

Article Designing Integrated Management Criteria of Creative Ideatio...

Can anyone help me with a step by step process of prepare questionnaire for AHP in expert choice software and convert the questionnaire to pdf fillable document, so that the responders can tick or click the options

Hi Mohsen Mazaheri Asad can you send me the AHP questionnaire as well, best wishes and thank you.

[email protected]

Fereshteh Ehsani,

Sure.

Hi Mohsen Mazaheri Asad can you please send me the AHP questionnaire too, best wishes and thank you in advance.

[email protected]

Sure, Ichrak.

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad , could you also send me the questionnaire you developed for a Fuzzy AHP analysis?

Thanks in advance.

my email address is [email protected]

Tharindu Karunaratne, yes, sure.

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Could you also send me the Fuzzy AHP analysis questionnaire?

Thanks in advance.

my email address is [email protected].

Sure, dear Sara.

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad, would you kindly share your Fuzzy AHP questionnaire? Would appreciate.

My email address is: [email protected].

Thank you so much.

Sure, dear @Penjani Hopkins Nyimbili.

You can use the Delphi method to collect expert’s opinions

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad,

Could you also send me the Fuzzy AHP analysis questionnaire?

Thank you so much

my email address is [email protected]

Sure, dear To Qhyen Le.

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad ,

Could you please share the AHP analysis questionnaire? Thank you so much.

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Would you kindly send your FAHP questionnaire?

Thank you in advance.

Here is my email address: [email protected]

Sure, dear @Sahar Heydarabadi

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad , Could you please send the AHP analysis questionnaire to me? Thanks in advance.

My email address: [email protected]

Dear Nur fatihah Afiqah

OK, sent.

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Would you kindly send your FAHP questionnaire?

Thank you so much.

My e-mail: [email protected]

Sure, dear @Eng Zaitoun

Thank you so much Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Would you kindly send your FAHP questionnaire?

Thank you so much.

My e-mail: [email protected]

Sure, dear Bita hellat abadi Farahani .

Dear Mohsen Mazaheri Asad ,

could you also send me the questionnaire you developed for a Fuzzy AHP analysis?

Thank you so much in advance.

My email address is [email protected]

Dear mohsen mazari Asad

Please send a copy of the questionnaire on email [email protected]

Sure, dear Atwijukire Gilbert .

Received.

Thank you

Hi Mohsen Mazaheri Asad ,

Can you please send me your FAHP questionnaire for reference?

My mail id is [email protected]

Good day Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Can you please send me your FAHP questionnaire on email [email protected]

Thank you!

Hi dear Krishnaveni K S

Sure, sent.

Thanks dear Kate Relucio

of course, it sent to your email.

Good day Dr Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Can I have the same copy of sample questionnaire as well? My email is [email protected]

Thank you

yes dear Mohammad FakhrulNizam Mohammad

sent.

Hi Mohsen Mazaheri Asad ,

Can you send me that questionnaire Fuzzy AHP ?

Email: [email protected]

Sure, dear Muhammad Nizar Alam , it is sent.

Hello Mohsen Mazaheri Asad

Can you please send me at [email protected], plz

Sanjit Maiti sure, it is sent.

Dear Professor Mohsen Mazaheri Asad Can you instruct me how to display the data of FAHP survey in excel, or just give me sample of data to create the FAHP pairwise matrix, I'm currently using R-studio to input and analyzing data, but not yet figured out the way of data structure

my email: [email protected]

Dear Tran Anh Tung , sure. I sent it to your email.