Did you select an appropriate cross sectional area at reference ? I think you might be doing mistake to consider cross sectional area. Please check it.
Make the computational domain larger enough (say 10D ) in both directions of the lift. Then use a slip boundary condition on the wall. I hope it helps.
As Aziz told, there should be no lift for a symmetric body. However, since you are doing unsteady simulations, you can see lift varying in time, due to vortex shedding, but the average value should be zero.