Dear Pierlorenzo Brignoli 

Thanks for such a nice contribution. Philosophy is also the result of thoughts processing, again based on Information, Knowledge & Imagination with diversity of sources. The element of wisdom in philosophy is due to its wider scope and coving huge sketch of experience and knowledge. So the publicly described difference between social and natural sciences are based on known, repeatable cause and effects. In a broader picture this said difference is loosing the gap if cause and effects are known. Which also indicates that any kind of Information, Knowledge & Imagination is not beyond the scope and ranges have roots in particles, field, force, wave etc and are physical entity.

Anyhow the arguments to reject /accept this hypothesis & for further applications are encouragingly welcome for a fruitful, healthy discussion.

Regards,

Dear Amrit Sorli

Thanks for a nice contribution.

Can you further explain this sentence stated in conclusion of your paper especially with reference to that that how & why this door get needs to remain "open"?

“The bridge between number 0 (non-manifested) and number 1 (manifested) is a mystery that one cannot fully understand by rational mind.”

Regards,

Information, knowledge and imagination in the human brain are certainly physical entities. The human brain treats information through chemical processes, which are basically physical working upon physical entities. Studies along the line described in the link below would clarify the working of the human brain more and more in the nearest future.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/05/090519152559.htm

Estimado Raja Khan NA

Gracias por invitarme a participar en este foro de discusión de alto nivel, donde se trata de entender y proporcionar evidencias respecto de si la Información, el Conocimiento y la Imaginación tienen Entidades Físicas. Dada la dificultad sintáctica, simbólica y semántica del lenguaje utilizado, expreso mi comentario en mi lengua nativa y en Inglés.

Cuestión difícil de contestar directamente sin pasar por el filtro de la reflexión y la experiencia respecto de estos temas, incluyendo la capacidad de expresar verbalmente y por escrito los pensamientos, reflexiones, ideas y especulación para el manejo conceptual y semántico de dichos términos, 

Sin temor me lanzo al vacío de la especulación utilizando el paracaídas de mi capacidad de introspección, navegando por las Entidades Físicas de la Información, Conocimiento e Imaginación, previa percepción, comprensión, asimilación, interpretación y respuesta consciente a los estímulos materiales corpusculares o energéticos ondulatorios (según teorías y resultados experimentales ya validados por la Física Relativista y por la Física Cuántica) que han llegado a mis terminaciones nerviosas, sinapsis, neuronas y centros nerviosos vitales de mi cerebro.

Estímulos que en forma veloz y automática se replican y amplifican para que yo me percate de su existencia, dada otra capacidad que ya poseo y que fue desarrollada por nuestra humanidad, durante milenios de desarrollo y evolución del Sistema Nervios Central, materializada en forma de la Consciencia, el percatarme (darme cuenta) de que algo sucede y existe fuera o dentro de mi, después de un cuidadoso proceso del manejo de información en forma de datos, imágenes, remembranzas. pensamientos e integración de todo ello gestando pensamientos más profundos con sentido y significado llamados reflexiones y retro-flexiones, esto es, el resultado superior de la consciencia y del pensamiento humano.. 

En síntesis y por lo anterior declaro que existe una relación indisoluble u ontológica entre Información, Conocimiento e Imaginación, que implican la existencia de Materia y Energía (en forma de fotones, ondas o cuantos) que se localizan al interior de mi cerebro y a nivel micro en el soma neuronal, el núcleo, mitocondrias, microtúbulos/ mofibrillas citoplásmicas de dichas neuronas, y también entre sus dendritas, axones y sinapsis. Todo ello un conjunto material y energético de Entidades Físicas.

Finalmente para terminar esta parte de mi disertación, considero que existen funciones superiores del cerebro, las que difícilmente podemos ubicar en un sustrato físico, esto es la Consciencia, la sensibilidad espiritual, la concepción ética y estética, los principios y los valores. Todo ello tiene un sustrato físico como sucede en todo manejo de la información en el cerebro, pero en ninguna parte de éste órgano u otro del cuerpo, podemos localizarlas en su forma terminal o completa.

Saludos

Dr. José Luis García Vigil

PD: Muy interesante y de acuerdo con gran parte del contenido de la publicación de Amrit Sorli, el cual guardé en mis archivos para una nueva lectura. Sin embargo no estoy de acuerdo con el símil efectuado de la consciencia como software y del cerebro como hardware. Esto es darle más importancia de la que ya tienen las computadoras y la inteligencia artificial.

Dear Raja Khan NA

Thank you for inviting me to participate in this forum for high-level discussion where it is to understand and provide evidence on whether the Information, Knowledge and Imagination are Physical Entities. Given the syntactical, symbolic and semantic difficulty of the language used, I express my comment in my native language and in English.

Difficult question to answer directly without going through the filter of reflection and experience on these issues, including the ability to express orally and in writing thoughts, reflections, ideas and speculation for conceptual and semantic management of these terms,

Without fear I throw myself into the void of speculation using the parachute of my capacity for introspection, navigating the Physical Entities, Information, Knowledge and Imagination, on perception, understanding, assimilation, interpretation and conscious response to material stimuli corpuscular or energy wavelike (as theories and experimental results already validated by relativistic physics and quantum physics) that have come to my nerve endings, synapses, neurons and vital nerve centers of my brain.

Stimuli as fast and automatically replicated and amplified so I became aware of its existence, given other capacity that already possess and which was developed by our humanity for millennia of development and evolution of the central nervous system, embodied in the form of the consciousness, my awareness (realize) that something happens and exists outside or inside me, after a careful process of information management in the form of data, images, remembrances. thoughts and integration of all gestating deeper meaning and significance thoughts and reflections retro-called push-ups, that is, the top result of consciousness and human thought ..

In summary and above I declare that there is an indissoluble or ontological relationship between Information, Knowledge and Imagination, which imply the existence of matter and energy (in the form of photons, waves or quanta) located inside my brain and micro level in neuronal soma, the nucleus, mitochondria, microtubule / cytoplasmic mofibrillas of said neurons, and also between their dendrites, axons and synapses. All this Material and Energetic set of Physical Entities.

Finally to end this part of my dissertation, I believe that there are higher brain functions, which can hardly be located on a physical substrate, this is Consciousness, spiritual sensitivity, ethical and aesthetic conception, principles and values. All this has a physical substrate as in all handling of information in the brain, but nowhere in this body or other body, we can locate them in your terminal or completely.

regards

Dr. Jose Luis Garcia Vigil

PS: Very interesting and agree with much of the content of the publication of Amrit Sorli, which I kept in my files for a new reading. However I do not agree with the simile made of consciousness as the brain as software and hardware. This is to give more importance than they already have computers and artificial intelligence.

According to me, all the three should happen in mind frame. Therefore, they are mental activities.

*Information is processed in brain.

*Knowledge is stored and assimilated in brain

*Imagination crops up in brain.

But the above three demands physical presence of a healthy brain.

They are not entities! They are notions.

Dear Napoleon Ono

Thanks a lot. Can you kindly further elaborate the "static state" mentioned in your answer.

Regards, 

Dear José Luis García Vigil 

Thanks for such a nice and helping contribution. After it, its making clue based mechanism that how words, languages might carry the energy from Information, Knowledge and Imaginations etc as a physical entity.

Regards,

Dear Jayaram M.A

Thanks for your contribution. Perhaps physical presence of a healthy brain might not the essential requirement for Information, Knowledge & Imagination, as they get unveil on in-volunteer & volunteer basis. There use in/for notions cant change the ultimate reality of them.

Regards,

Dear Tatsuo Tabata 

Thanks for a nice contribution. Agree with you. 

Regards,

Yes, information, knowledge and imagination have direct linkage with the human brain, which resides in our head. They are output of a black box, the thru-put in   which we can not see,  as the process is  intangible. Nevertheless; but the processes through which they are produced are very much physical; for the brain releases chemicals while producing these.

Dear Debi S. Saini

Thanks for a nice contribution. It means that all kinds of  information, knowledge and imagination must have physical source behind it.

Regards,

Dear Raja

Sure they are physical entities, information knowledge and imagination are connecting human characteristic and controlling.  

 Knowledge is power & knowledgeable person would all the time think -ponder to make his mind perfect to store the knowledge for which he may come out for his own purpose & quite good for contribution of the society .

A knowledge is visible ,face is a mirror & knowledgeable person can also be viewed by his personal image in the form of his forehead ,Eyes,& overall appearance .

His physical Entities cannot be measured but because of his simplicity ,living style & his other social norms ,it has been observed that the person with standing with his reputation & his well to do riches with his living style ,he is observing such knowledgeable person in his much below level .

Knowledgeable person is ignoring this fact but to me for such other persons of his standing forget the basic fact that after his departure on this earth ,he will merely remember with his name for sometime but for knowledgeable person even after his final journey he will remember all the time with his message for future generation .

This is my personal opinion 

Human brain is a complex processor, which processes information, knowledge from physical sources; but imagination, neither have physical source nor it is processed by human brain. Imagination is the result of creation of thought waves in human mind, which may eventually connect to a creative domain.