To my knowledge all criteria should be satisfied to diagnose the Stiff Person Syndrome (formerly known as the Stiff Man Syndrome). These criteria have been satisfied in the three patients I had to deal with and I believe are common to all patients with SPS.
Currently accepted clinical criteria for the diagnosis of stiff-person syndrome :
(1) insidious onset of muscular rigidity with difficulty turning or bending, with rigidity most prominent in the limbs and axial muscles, especially abdominal and thoracolumbar;
(2) co-contraction of agonist and antagonist muscles, confirmed clinically and electrophysiologically;
(3) episodic spasms superimposed on the underlying rigidity, precipitated by noise, tactile stimuli, or emotional upset;
(4) absence of other neurologic or other diseases that could explain the symptoms