What is the most effective and experienced biocontrol method for managing the ONION MAGGOT (Delia antiqua) fly in organic free-field agriculture? It poses a threat to organic onion production in Austria. Johann HUMER, Vienna, Austria
You could try using seed treatments of Spinosad. It is labeled as Lumiverd in the US (https://www.corteva.us/products-and-solutions/seed-treatments/lumiverd.html). In the past, it was labeled as Regard, which provided control for maggots (https://academic.oup.com/amt/article/48/1/tsad041/7111169). I'm not sure if it's labeled for use in Austria.
Controlling onion maggot (Delia antiqua) in organic fields can be challenging, but there are several biocontrol methods and cultural practices that can help manage the pest. Here are some strategies you can consider:
Natural enemies: natural enemies that are most likely to prey on the eggs and small maggots are soil-dwelling species. The most common are predatory mites, staphylinid beetles (Rove beetle), and carabid beetles (Ground beetles). They are all favoured by soils that are rich in organic matter. Introduce or encourage beneficial parasitic wasps (e.g., Aphidius colemani) that prey on onion maggots or their eggs.
2. Beneficial Nematodes (Steinernema feltiae): These microscopic organisms can be applied to the soil to target onion maggot larvae. Beneficial nematodes infect and kill the larvae, providing a natural and organic control method.
Neem Oil: Neem oil is derived from the neem tree and has insecticidal properties. It can be used as a foliar spray to deter onion maggot adults and disrupt their life cycle.
Companion Planting: Planting onions alongside other crops that repel onion maggots can be helpful. For example, planting aromatic herbs like rosemary, thyme, or mint can act as natural repellents.
Crop Rotation: Rotate onion crops with non-host plants to break the life cycle of onion maggots. Avoid planting onions in the same location year after year.
Floating Row Covers: Use floating row covers to physically prevent adult flies from laying eggs on onion plants. Be sure to secure the covers tightly to prevent any gaps.
Trap Crops: Plant trap crops to attract onion maggot adults away from the main onion crop. These trap crops can be treated or removed to reduce the overall pest population.
Sanitation Practices: Remove and destroy infested plant material promptly to reduce the population of onion maggots in the field.
Diatomaceous Earth: Sprinkle food-grade diatomaceous earth around onion plants. This substance damages the exoskeletons of insects, including onion maggots, causing them to dehydrate and die.
Kaolin Clay: Applying kaolin clay to the foliage forms a barrier that can deter onion maggot adults and make it difficult for them to lay eggs.
Remember that a combination of these methods may be more effective than relying on a single strategy. Regular monitoring of the onion crop and early intervention are key components of successful pest management in organic farming. Additionally, local agricultural extension services can provide specific recommendations based on the region and the severity of the infestation.
1. Application of entomopathogenic fungi (EPF) in the soil before sowing of the onion. Compost can be used as a carrier of the fungi. So in this case, the application can be done during spring or post-harvest of onions in autumn.
2. Spraying of different EPF and botanical pesticides in combination. This can help reduce the hatching of eggs and if they hatch, the larvae can get infected with the EPF or poisoned by botanical pesticide.
Note, in case of Neem derived pesticide for spraying, the chemical constituents are sensitive to light. So spraying needs to be done after sunset only, for maximum efficacy.
I have experience in both during my PhD so I can assure you that neem and EPF are symbionts.