Using the same probe and on the same PCR plate, both abnormal Taqman qPCR multicomponent plot normal Taqman qPCR multicomponent plot were observed. The only difference between the two is the template. Then what is the problem?
My first guess would be there is too high a concentration of template DNA in the "abnormal" reactions. Did you standardize your template concentrations using a nanodrop?
To me it also looks like a too high template concentration. Have you tried doing a dilution of your sample. Looking at your curves i would assume you should try diluting by a factor of 100 to 1000.