28 Questions 642 Answers 0 Followers
Questions related from Nolberto Munier
I explain here my poits of view. I would very much like the opinion of colleagues
24 August 2022 9,148 0 View
The immediately answer without too much thinking would possibly be: Yes, we need them, because not all criteria have the same importance, and this is true. Fine, now what are criteria weights?...
12 April 2021 3,399 36 View
Dear colleagues I want to thank those that request copies of my publications and many people have written me asking for them. It is an honor and a satisfaction that people think that they can...
01 January 1970 9,673 4 View
These are my comments on the paper published by Udaykamar Kashid and others
01 January 1970 8,019 1 View
Most MCDM problems use subjective weights mainly obtained from AHP. These weights are developed by preferences, qualified using a dubious table (as is the opinion of many researchers), and...
01 January 1970 3,269 5 View
In my opinion, AHP has many drawbacks that make it very difficult to use in MCDM problems, even being the most used method. In my opinion, this happens because many practitioners ignore the...
01 January 1970 9,278 9 View
Dear Mr.Ibrahim Badi and coauthors, Željko Stević , Muhammad Lawan Jibril I have read your paper “Using the MCDM Approach to Evaluate Smart and Sustainable Cities” These are my comments. 1- I...
01 January 1970 4,543 0 View
Dear Irik Mukhametzyanov and Dragan Pamucar I have read your paper Sensitivity analysis in MCDM problems: A statistical approach My comments: On page 3 you say “Consequentially, the...
01 January 1970 7,100 0 View
Dear: Jean Dezert , Albena Tchamovag, Deqiang Han, Jean-Marc Tacne Reference is made to your paper : The SPOTIS Rank Reversal Free Method for Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Support My comments...
01 January 1970 6,598 1 View
Dear Mahmut I have read the paper that you and your colleagues wrote on: “Exploring the Specific Capacity of Different Multi Criteria Decision Making Approaches under Uncertainty using Data from...
01 January 1970 5,960 0 View
350 – An attempt to explain Rank Reversal (RR) and reasonable inferences for its manifestations Nolberto Munier Given a set of different alternatives or products subject to a set of criteria or...
01 January 1970 6,573 0 View
Dear Nguyen Hong Son,T ran Trung Hieu Reference is made to your article: SELECTION OF WELDING ROBOT BY MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION MAKING METHOD I have read your article and my comments are: 1. In...
01 January 1970 1,405 0 View
Dear Jakub Wieckowski , Zdzisław Szyjewskib I have read your paper: Practical Study of Selected Multi-Criteria Methods Comparison Here are some of my comments 1 You say “It can be seen that the...
01 January 1970 7,411 0 View
Dear Ivana Mladenovic and co-authors I have read your paper: “Multicriteria Decision Analysis of Sites with Increased Nutrient Contents in Water “ Here are my comments 1- It is no doubt a very...
01 January 1970 9,969 0 View
Dear Mr. Duong and coauthors I have read your article: “Expert opinion-based multi objective optimization: an application in plasma coating technology” And here are my comments: 1- In page 1...
01 January 1970 6,533 0 View
Dear Monayem Parvej, Soupayan Mitra, Shankha Shubhra Goswami Reference is made to your article: An Integrated Approach of AHP and TOPSIS for Optimum Selection of Renewable Energy Source I have...
01 January 1970 6,645 2 View
Dear colleagues Along the years I have written many papers on MCDM on almost every aspect. From them, I have selected 40 articles addressing different topics. Often one topic has more than one...
01 January 1970 4,970 7 View
Dear Mohammad Masfiqul Alam Bhuiyan and Ahmed Hamma I read your paper: A Hybrid Multi-Criteria Decision Support System for Selecting the Most Sustainable Structural Material for a Multistory...
01 January 1970 9,068 4 View
Dear Nguyen Hong Son, Tran Trung Hieu, Nguyen Manh Thang, Huynh Nhu Tan, Nguyen Tien Can, Nguyen Chi Bao I have read your paper CHOOSING THE BEST MACHINE TOOL IN MECHANICAL MANUFACTURING And these...
01 January 1970 7,346 0 View
Dear Xu, Tianming Liu, Wei; Zhu, Zicheng I read your paper: Multi-criteria decision-making methods applied to achieve sustainable design: A systematic review My comments 1- in the Abstract you...
01 January 1970 5,140 0 View
Dear Ms. Dobricic and Milica Dobričić, Mladen Šljivović , Milena Cvetković I have read your article 1- In page 3 you say “In recent years, an increasing number of authors believe that SWOT...
01 January 1970 5,938 0 View
Dear Majid Baseer, Christian Ghiaus * , Roxane Viala , Ninon Gauthier and Souleymane Daniel I read your paper pELECTRE-Tri: Probabilistic ELECTRE-Tri Method—Application for the Energy Renovation...
01 January 1970 8,526 0 View
Dear Mahak Bhatia, Aled Williams I have read your paper Selection of Criteria Using MCDM Techniques - An Application in Renewable Energy My comments are as follows: 1- Using MCDM to determine...
01 January 1970 677 0 View
Dear Mr. Rukhshanda Rehman , Muhammad Sagheer Aslam , Elzbieta Jasinska, Muhammad Faisal Javed and Miroslava Gono I read your paper “Guidelines for the Technical Sustainability Evaluation of the...
01 January 1970 2,483 0 View
Dear Wojcieh Salabun and coauthors: Bartłomiej Kizielewicz , Andrii Shekhov Reference is made to your article “ pymcdm—The universal library for solving multi-criteria decision-making...
01 January 1970 2,287 4 View
Dear Ms. Uribe and co-authors I have read with great interest your paper: “A SUDS Planning Decision Support Tool to Maximize Ecosystem Services” My comments are as follows: 1- The paper...
01 January 1970 4,123 0 View
Dear Sofian Boukhari Thank you for your request to review your article Utilizing a combined Delphi-FAHP-TOPSIS technique to assess the effectiveness of the water supply service in Algeria These...
01 January 1970 3,002 0 View
Dear Mohamad Shahiir Saidin, Lai Soon Lee, Siti Mahani Marjugi , Muhammad Zaini Ahmad and Hsin-Vonn Seow I have read your paper Fuzzy Method Based on the Removal Effects of Criteria (MEREC) for...
01 January 1970 8,832 0 View
