They are both deuterated Methanol, and if you are going to use them is a water solution it won't make a difference since the CD3OD will exchange the D with H in water and become CD3OH. The difference in price I think is only due to the fact that CD3OD has been discontinued and you will get and old stock from Sigma. But again, if you are going to add it to water, it wont matter, go for the cheapest product.