What COMSOL can do that Abaqus cannot?

Vinh Phu Nguyen @Vinh_Phu_Nguyen

09 September 2016 0 4K Report

Hi all,

I would like to know in which areas that comsol is better than abaqus or ansys?

bests,

phu

Badges
Science topic

More Vinh Phu Nguyen's questions See All

What is the current status of Abaqus XFEM?

Dear colleagues, I would like to use the XFEM module in Abaqus but do not know what is there. So, what I would like to know is: (1) Can it do 3D crack growth? (2) Can it do both LEFM and...

09 October 2017 622 7 View

Which is the best reference for limit analyses of frames using linear programming?

08 September 2016 1,439 2 View

Are limit analyses still being used for design?

Dear all, I am teaching a course on manual limit analyses (yield line theories and Hillerborg's strip method) for reinforced concrete structures. I am not sure whether they are being used in...

06 July 2016 9,191 11 View

What are the strengths and weaknesses of LS-Dyna compared to Abaqus and vice versa?

I am novice at commercial FE packages, but I would like to try them. However I am not sure which one to choose. Your expert feedbacks are very much appreciated. And are those FE packages working...

04 May 2016 8,181 7 View

Resistor definition in Piezoelectric bimorph with ANSYS workbench

Hello, good day! I am trying to simulate similar bimorph piezoelectric harvester with below commands. However, the output power doesn't change with resistor value. Please help to find the reason. ET,10,CIRCU94,0 !SET UP RESISTOR R,1,100000 !RESISTANCE VALUE TYPE,10 !SET ELEMENT TYPE E,1,2 !CREATE RESISTOR BETWEEN NODES 1 AND 2 Thanks in advance Regards,

02 March 2021 0 0 View

Is there any tutorial for comsol general projections?

Hi, im trying to make a projection in a 3d comsol model. I have a non uniforme chanel and my intention is to get the average tempreture in the y-z cross section and se the average tempreture...

02 March 2021 4,624 4 View

Why are the velocities so high in my Boussinesq approximation Fluent simulation?

Hello, I have a mechanism where air rises due to convective flows. In this simulation, nothing is driving the air except this. I understand that the Boussinesq approximation only works for small...

02 March 2021 4,910 3 View

Is it possible to do piezoelectric coupling in ANSYS-APDL or COMSOL between tapered substrate and rectangular piezoelectric patch?

How to do Piezoelectric coupling in ANSYS-APDL or COMSOL between tapered substrate and rectangular piezoelectric patch? Piezoelectric coupling between the rectangular substrate and rectangular...

02 March 2021 9,833 3 View

How to define and get results (stresses) for certain points of a model in abaqus, using python? When the size of the model changes?

I want to do a parameter study of a aixsymmetric cylinder in Abaqus. I want to create several jobs where I get the stresses for 3 different points in my model. These points are defined. I wrote a...

01 March 2021 10,078 1 View

LOAD DISPLACEMENT CURVES Stiffness increasing in ANSYS non linear analysis. HOW CAN I CORRECT IT?

Hi. I am doing non linear FE analysis using a new material beam under flexural 2 point loading using ANSYS. I have defined a bilinear material model. The solution has converged. In results I am...

01 March 2021 9,911 3 View

Joint behaviour in Abaqus is not captured well?

I am working on roof joint and trying to simulate the behaviour in Abaqus. I am successful in running the model but the final graph does not follow the experimental curve in the negative direction...

01 March 2021 6,661 3 View

How to show arrows over the streamlines in CFD-post?

I follow this to make streamlines like the photos attached below: (software- CFD post-processing) First I plot the 2D streamline over a surface "streamline 1". them I plot a vector by the...

01 March 2021 8,668 3 View

Which one is easier and better at modeling slender masonry structures? ANSYS or ABAQUS?

I need to model masonry and reinforced concrete minarets for my MSc thesis. Which one is easier and better at modeling slender masonry structures? ANSYS or ABAQUS? (Or any other program for just...

01 March 2021 736 3 View

Can Virtual Servers (remote dekstop manager) run heavy ANSYS Fluent CFD simulation ?

I have a virtual machine. My host Pc specs are not that good thats why i went for virtual servers. so basically my host pc has 8gb of ram with nvidia quadro k2200 4Gb DDR5 GPU ,processor intel...

01 March 2021 8,415 1 View