I believe no.
think physics overeliance on problem calculations creates lazy thinkers, because the hase study on typical knowledge, exam archetype problems, routines etc
I think that essays are insdequate to asses physics is a misconception.
Critical thinking criteria can be assesed via difficult essay questions i.e role of proper time in SR that demand conceptual growth,synthesis, deep understanding of mathematical formulas & theory
Maybe less skills on managing formalism, but still critical thinking if a level worthy of gaining a masters and proving credentials for worthy research.
Maybe a partial skillset test to be acompanied as degree requirement, partial fulfillment, not as the core as it exists.
I think physics overeliance on problem calculations creates lazy thinkers, because the hase study on typical knowledge, exam archetype problems, routines etc
Philippos Afxentiou
I think it depends on how the questions and problems are formulated. I remember when I was a grad student in Calgary there were some international students in engineering complaining about "trick questions" even though there was nothing tricky about them. The problem was that, as you suggest, the students came from a background of rote learning and stereotypical tasks. When they were required to think slightly outside the box, they floundered.
Philippos Afxentiou
These may be of interest to you:
- https://enlightenedidiot.net/random/feynman-on-brazilian-education-system/
- http://calteches.library.caltech.edu/46/2/LatinAmerica.htm?fbclid=IwAR0lm8Oj0akeah5m8oBSM2JauABDwXp0AU9u6DKa_2mHzEvaMMbdleeeAf4