How much does usually a second/third round of revisions for a journal take?

Jean-Michel Clairand @Jean_Michel_Clairand

01 January 1970 1 10K Report

I submitted a manuscript to a Springer Journal. I have already received two rounds of revisions, the two times major. In the second letter, the two other reviewers accepted already my paper, and the third asked still for major revisions, but just asking for style comments. However, my paper is now in the third round of revisions, and the status is "Under review" for more than one month. So I was wondering why it takes so long. Have you experienced similar waiting time for the second or third revision?

Grzegorz Boczkaj

if it is after major revision - few weeks.

If minor - sometimes few days, sometimes 1 day - depends if all reviewers need to approve it or only Editor review your answers.

regards,

Badges
Science topic

More Jean-Michel Clairand's questions See All

What can I do when the Associate and Editor in Chief give different decisions for a paper?

I have submitted a paper in a binary peer-review journal. The associate editor sent me the decision that my paper was rejected but encouraged to resubmit with changes. The 3 reviewers found my...

08 September 2018 6,988 9 View

Transform a function curve in another with the same trend in new interval?

Hello, I have a function f(x) with its respective curve, that has a minimum (let assume 1), a mean (5) and a maximum value (9) defined in some steps. I want to create a function g(x) with the...

04 May 2018 4,428 0 View

Operating reserves for solar and wind for microgrid planning?

I am looking for a paper which defines operating reserves for solar and wind, as power outputs, as possible 25 % for solar and 50 % for wind, in order to justify the parameters I used in my...

01 February 2018 283 3 View

Has anyone submitted a paper to IEEE Access?

I am in a hurry to get a paper published the sooner possible. I am interested of IEEE Access. If anyone has send a paper to IEEE access, I want to know their feedback of the journal. Do you...

31 December 2017 6,976 3 View

What is the best distribution function for this case?

I want to generate random numbers from a distribution function. This distribution function has its values defined between [4;24] and has the maximum probability in 7. I attach the density function...

08 September 2016 8,438 3 View

Generating n matrices in matlab with "for" loop?

04 May 2016 6,148 4 View

Order ascending values in matrices?

I have n matrices, with values in the first line. I want in the second line the ascending order of the values from each column. For example:n=3 A{1}=[1,2,3,4], A{2}=[10,11,12,13],...

04 May 2016 7,191 0 View

What is the better optimizer tool between GAMS and Gurobi?

Based on your expertise, what is the better optimizer tool between GAMS ( https://www.gams.com/ ) and Gurobi ( https://www.gurobi.com/ )? Please also let me know your field of research.

01 January 1970 7,652 5 View

Which environment is better between Matlab and Python to design deep learning models?

Based on your expertise, which environment do you find the better between Matlab and Python to design deep learning models? Python is free and you have a lot of libraries, but in the case you have...

01 January 1970 8,861 13 View

What techniques can I use to determine the miscibility of polymer blends?

The term miscibility refers to the single-phase state in thermodynamics. I do not mean the compatibility of different components. To determine the miscibility I know several techniques such as...

03 March 2021 4,107 4 View

New Journal, "Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science" -- do you not know, and have you not seen, this done before?

Question to you and THEM, the New Journal, "Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science" -- do you not know, and have you not seen, this done before? There appears to be a core problem for...

02 March 2021 3,024 2 View

How to add a journal?

I would like to know how to register the journal Flora Montiberica (ISSN 1138-5952 - eISSN 1988-799X) in Research Gate.

02 March 2021 8,156 2 View

Is it possible to remove a preprint posted by a journal which is already rejected?

As we know many journals are posting preprints (DOI) in advance before the peer-review process. However, there is no guarantee that the preprints get published. The journal's reviewers undergo the...

01 March 2021 5,778 2 View

No title

Hi, I have several doubts about one paper (Systematic Literature Review) that was rejected. The main topic is Single-Board Computers in engineering education during the period 2010-2020. The...

01 March 2021 9,015 3 View

How to figure out easily the right journal with the right scope for your paper?

According to my experience most of the selected journals during paper submission are based on journal text matching suggested results from Springer, Elsevier,,,Etc. then the manuscript happened to...

01 March 2021 1,786 3 View

Any research paper call for publication related to management or finance or economics?

It should be standard journal (Indexed)

01 March 2021 8,379 1 View

What is the most reliable source to get Impact factor of journals?

Source to get Impact factor of journals

01 March 2021 6,654 2 View

How to highlight novelty in your research paper?

I have come up with a method and had written a paper on it. Paper got rejected by a journal stating that there is no theoretical novelty. I am kind of confused on why the novelty that I am able to...

28 February 2021 2,393 8 View

Is Journal of Agricultural Research a predator?

it is published by Juniper

28 February 2021 354 4 View