I am attempting to amplify a section of a plasmid that I have mutated to test for mutation. My primers are mutation-specific. My positive sample shows a band of the correct size (water, primers, dNTPs, buffer, taq, mutated template). My mutation control has no band (water, primers, dNTPs, buffer, taq, unmutated template). But my water control has the same sized band as my positive (water, primers, dNTPs, buffer, taq). I have done this experiment before with no issues, so I don't believe it is a problem with the PCR protocol (annealing temps, number of cycles, etc). However, I can't believe it is a contamination problem because I don't get this same band in my mutation control. I have tried new master mixes three times, double checking each time to make sure I didn't make a loading error. I make the master mix in a separate room using filter tips. Any advice would be appreciated.