It has been reported that biochars can retain anions, such as nitrate and phosphate. Specific adsorption could explain P retention, but positive charge must be present to electrostatically retain nitrate. pH of zero net charge of some biochars has also been reported at pH 6 to 8, meaning at pH below 6 biochar would carry a lot of positive charge. Oxonium (O-H3+) has been proposed. Yet, from a chemistry standpoint, this cation seems unlikely under normal soil conditions. New explanations for + charge on biochar are appreciated.