According to Shannon's definition, entropy measures information, choice, and uncertainty. Then, does negative differential entropy imply small uncertainty, less choice, and little information?
Zhicheng Lei
Differential entropy is an infinitesimal change in entropy. A negative change in the differential entropy means a small change in the decrease in information, choice.
### What is Differential Entropy?
First, let's understand what differential entropy is. Traditional entropy, as defined by Shannon for discrete random variables, is always non-negative. It measures the average unpredictability of a random variable. The more unpredictable it is, the higher its entropy.
However, when we move from discrete random variables (like flipping a coin) to continuous random variables (like measuring someone's height), we use differential entropy. Unlike the traditional entropy, differential entropy can be negative.
### Why Can Differential Entropy Be Negative?
Imagine you have a box, and inside this box, you have a certain amount of "information" or "uncertainty." In the discrete world, you can't have less than an empty box (0). But in the continuous world, it's like you can have a box that goes "underground" or "below the floor level." This "underground" space represents the negative values of differential entropy.
### What Does Negative Differential Entropy Mean?
Now, to the heart of the question: What does it mean when the box goes "underground"?
1. **Small Uncertainty**: A negative differential entropy doesn't necessarily mean there's "negative uncertainty" (because uncertainty can't be negative). Instead, it's a relative measure. Compared to a reference distribution (like the Gaussian distribution), a negative value indicates that the distribution in question is "more certain" or "less spread out."
2. **Less Choice**: In the context of information theory, "choice" refers to the number of possible outcomes or the spread of a distribution. A negative differential entropy suggests that the distribution is more "peaked" or "concentrated" around certain values, implying fewer choices or less variability.
3. **Little Information**: Information, in this context, refers to the unpredictability or randomness of outcomes. A more negative differential entropy means the outcomes are more predictable, and thus, there's less new information to be gained from observations.
### In Simple Terms:
Imagine you're trying to guess the weight of a random apple from a basket. If almost all apples weigh the same (say, around 150 grams), then your guess will likely be close, and there's little uncertainty or surprise. This situation can be represented by a negative differential entropy. On the other hand, if the weights of apples vary a lot, it's harder to guess, and there's more uncertainty, leading to a higher entropy value.
So, negative differential entropy doesn't mean "negative information" or "negative uncertainty." Instead, it's a way to say that, relative to some reference, the continuous random variable in question is more predictable, concentrated, and offers less new information.
The differential entropy of a random variable is a measure of its uncertainty or randomness. It is defined as the expected value of the negative logarithm of the probability density function of the random variable.
In general, the differential entropy is non-negative. However, it can be negative for certain distributions, such as the uniform distribution on the interval (0, 1/2). This is because the uniform distribution assigns equal probability to all values in the interval, which means that there is no uncertainty about the value of the random variable.
A negative differential entropy can be interpreted as a situation where we have more information than we need to describe the random variable. For example, if we know that a random variable follows a uniform distribution on the interval (0, 1/2), then we can completely specify its value by simply saying that it is in that interval. We do not need to know any more information than that.
In other words, a negative differential entropy indicates that the random variable is more structured or less random than a random variable with a positive differential entropy.
Here are some examples of distributions with negative differential entropy:
- The uniform distribution on the interval (0, 1/2)
- The Gaussian distribution with a very small variance
- The Cauchy distribution
It is important to note that the differential entropy is not the only measure of uncertainty or randomness. Other measures, such as the Kullback-Leibler divergence, can also be negative. However, the differential entropy is a commonly used measure and its interpretation is relatively straightforward.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Mathematics
- Statistics
- Sampling Design
- Sample Size