I have sent a research paper to a journal. In that paper ,I selected the punch diameter of 5 mm.

The reviewer comment is as follows:

"The punch diameter of the forming parts in this paper is 5mm, and it is too big. In addition, commercial finite element software is not suitable for micro forming, because of the size effect is not considered."

I want to know the idea from anyone and  I have to reply to the reviewer.

Thanking you,

by

M.Subramanian

More Bala Subramanian's questions See All
Similar questions and discussions