Currently I'm using "Restore plus western blot Stripping Buffer" for reprobing a new antibody on my blots. I am not that happy with the results because the residues of first use are still there!
First, what kind of antibody are you trying to strip off? Certain ones, especially for phosphorylated proteins don't like to come off. You might as well run a second gel for total protein. Second, I am not familiar with the stripping solution you are using. How long do you leave it on your membrane? What temperature? All these details are important. The higher the antibody affinity, the harder it is to strip off. Pierce's stripping solution is pretty good. Be careful when using these kind of solutions, as they impact antigens in your membrane, which impacts the secondary detection you are hoping to perform.