According to an article I've read, reaction path for the formation of Cu from CuO can come from the direct reduction of CuO to Cu or from the dissolution of CuO to Cu2+ ions leading to Cu.
In the paper, it was concluded that Cu nanoparticles were produced from the reduction of Cu2+ ions from the dissolution of CuO because direct reduction of CuO to Cu would have yielded Cu particles with roughly the same diameter as CuO particles, 3 um.
Is particle size enough evidence to believe that dissolution was the reaction path mechanism?
I'm having doubts because presence of Cu2+ should show a blue tinge in the solution which never happened. Also, CuO is barely soluble in water so it would not have been possible for CuO to be completely dissociated to Cu2+ and OH-. I'm angling for the direct reduction mechanism.
What are your thoughts on this? Is it possible that direct mechanism occurred? What are some evidences of direct reduction from CuO to Cu in aqueous solution?
Thank you very much!