If you did the colony PCR, it is possible that your PCR amplification is due to your gene fragment contamination during the transformation. If you can specifically PCR amplify the insert from your miniprep DNA, the colony you picked could be a forced ligation of a damaged overhang resulting your restriction enzyme site change. If that is the case, you should see a slight size difference of your plasmid in compare with wild type (It is rare both RE sites are changed), and verify it by sequencing.
Be sure to include a negative control in your PCR. This disparity is likely due to contamination. Use primers for sequences in the plasmid, not the insert and you should produce a small fragment from negative clones and a larger +444 bp product from positive clones. You can then use those same primers for sequencing to verify.
I agree with Jay, use vector primers, or find new restriction sites in the vector that flank your insert and try cutting with those. you will either get 444 + the vector bits, or a small band for the vector bits alone.