We have been torturing Tokamaks for 70 years. We have no results. Now we are building ITER worth more than 20 billion euros. It will be experimental only.Maybe we should go back to basics? Understand that there is a charge, that there is a mass, how the alpha particle is arranged. We need to understand how the Sun works. Please read the book "Electromagnetic gravity. Part 2" in my profile. In the solar corona, the ions rush towards each other. Electromagnetic field provides pushing forces. Do you agree with my suggestions on this topic?
what are your alternatives?
perhaps General Fusion's ideas would function.
Dear Esmat,
I hope that You have read my book "Electromagnetic Gravity. Part 2". What is not clear for You in the book?
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin
Dear Valeriy Pakulin
I have not read your book. But I feel that trying new idea is always better, Once it is experimentally feasible. Idea of tokamak is alright, but unfortunately it is taking more time than expected due to emergence of various types of instabilities in the plasma that needs to be controlled. Controlling some problem needs better understanding of the phenomenon that takes time depending on the situation in every experiment.
Dear Virendra.
I do not understand what your reply about. I propose a new idea and want to discuss it with experts. But if you have not read my book, how can you discuss it?
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin
Dear Valeriy Pakulin ,
Strange your question?
First, a Tokamak can now prove to be a controlled thermonuclear fusion reactor. No machine has been studied so much by generations of researchers around the world.
There are no miracles in science! No one will wake up in the morning and "trip" over a nuclear fusion machine in backyard. Only if are alien!
Researchers' efforts since the 1930s must at least be respected.
Do you really think that so many governments and researchers have spent time, money and their lives on something that was not worth it?
Over the years, thousands of machines built of the Tokamak type, the solution became clear after the experiments carried out at JET. Its small proportion (spherical) shape, its plasma column surface and its area are fundamental for obtaining nuclear fusion and sustaining a reactor.
In any case, we will see if the nuclear fusion scientific community was right, ITER is almost ready to respond to skeptics.
However, I respect your opinion.
Regards,
Wiltgen
Filipe Wiltgen
Dear Filipe,
I thank you for your kind words. Alas, ITER also has a failed project. Because nothing has been changed there, except for the scale. I'm talking about the need to change our very ideas about the microcosm.
1. Nucleons in the nucleus are not repulsed by charges. They themselves (cold) strive for each other. I say the same about electrons. In the flow, electrons are pulled together (the arc is laced during welding).
2. We only need to repeat the thermonuclear reactor of the Sun, where the reactions take place in the corona.
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin
Dear Valeriy ,
Ok, do you really think ITER the largest consortium of countries ever created in the world is building a machine 20 years ago, with hundreds of researchers and global collaboration never seen just for vanity?
I have been a thermonuclear fusion researcher in Tokamak for 30 years and to this day I haven't seen anything that far supports any opinion like yours ("ITER also has a failed project??? "). Nonsense, I think you need to know one more Tokamaks.
You still find your question without any practical or constructive feeling for obtaining nuclear fusion on Earth, perhaps with a gravity and density of matter equal to that of the sun, it is really possible to just look at the stars, everyone knows that, don't be new to that!
Are you a nuclear fusion engineer or nuclear fusion physicist? What is your proposal for a feasible engineer nuclear fusion machine on Earth?
Unfortunately, I know that here on Earth it will only be possible to achieve nuclear fusion with large, Tokamaks-type machines.
Wait until 2025 !!!!
Sincerely,
Wiltgen
Tokamak will work with success if not for 20 years, it will be happened for 200 years. If it will be not happened in UK, EU and Russia, it will be happened in USA, China, Japan and S. Korea.
Yes, it is true!!! Tokamak, it is and has always been most promising machine for achieving controlled nuclear fusion on Earth!
Filipe Wiltgen
Danilo Rastovic
My dear friends, God grant us to live to see this!..
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin
Dear Valeriy Pakulin,
Thank you for your kindness and retribution, wishing everyone that we are alive and with great health and perseverance!
Best Regards,
Wiltgen
Danilo Rastovic
Dear Danilo, you are most welcome. And I am not interested for my own promotion. Thank you so very much. СПАСИБО ЗА РУССКИЙ!!! ПРИВЕТ ИЗ ПИТЕРА!!!..
PS
If you will have some free time, please look at my site http://gravity.spb.ru
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin
I want walk accross Nevski Prospect but I am a little old and I don't have money. ( Mne interesirujut pamjatniki na Universitete na Vasilevskom ostrve- Mendeleev,Lyapunov, Chebisev, Markov...). I have got the sculpture of Nikola Tesla , here in Zagreb.
Danilo Rastovic
Dear Danilo,
I can sent you the folder with views of St. Petersburg, if you want, of cause.
My e-mail:
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin
Dear Valeriy Pakulin, many thanks. During my stay in Leningrad, I obtained several papers from one Russian mathematician and it helped me to make my PhD . I was in Leningrad with one exellent Man from India who helped me learn the English on the level of free conversation. Next, the works of Mendeleev, Lyapunov, Chebishev and Markov helped me in my research further ( deuterium - tritium operation, stability of the plasma in the sense of Lyapunov, nonlinearity and approximation and fuzzy Markovian processes ( deep learning, machine learning) are connected with tokamak theory ).
Ijaz Durrani
Dear Ijaz,
I thank You so very much!
Yours
Valeriy Pakulin