If I find a big mistake or wrong method of solution in a published paper; what should I do?
1. Write a technical note to the same journal.
2. Write a technical note to another journal.
3. Write a technical note to the authors of the paper.
It is possible - and it's an obligation, I think - to mention the mistake in an appropriate way in your paper.
I propose to publish a letter to the editor in the same journal.
Thanks for all of you for your valuable answers. However, I still need your advise for this situation, because I have derived the write solution and I want to publish my work.
Regards
Dear researchers; What is your advice to find better selection of journal for my future publication? What should I care more about? 1. Strong relation between paper topic and journal topic or 2....
04 May 2018 1,862 12 View
Through a single stream of flow we have a device like pump or turbine and we want to analyze the flow before and after the device. Can we do that by using ANSYS when the device is only considered...
11 December 2017 1,410 1 View
I have conducted and published a systematic review and meta-analysis research with the topic related to public health and health pomotion (protocol was registed in PROSPERO). Now we want to...
03 March 2021 8,920 3 View
How to upload pdf of my articles published?
03 March 2021 2,183 3 View
Hi everyone, I'm studying Marketing and I would like to write my PhD thesis on the topic of pricing. Any specific ideas?
02 March 2021 9,706 5 View
We are analysing scientific reports at University in great detail, so I wanted to find a scientific report about how to write a scientific report. Including detail such as what information to put...
02 March 2021 7,602 4 View
Question to you and THEM, the New Journal, "Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science" -- do you not know, and have you not seen, this done before? There appears to be a core problem for...
02 March 2021 3,024 2 View
I would like to know how to register the journal Flora Montiberica (ISSN 1138-5952 - eISSN 1988-799X) in Research Gate.
02 March 2021 8,156 2 View
There are some books published in LAP. Shall I add it to the RG?
02 March 2021 2,753 1 View
We have one plant, the local people using this for controlling blood sugar, the toxicity and antidiabetic activity of the plant is not reported yet, please guide from whag should be the process ?...
02 March 2021 2,300 1 View
How do I do energy minimization in lammps with NVT ensemble ? I am using the following command and it does not seem to work. It stops at extremely high energy and gives me the error zero search...
01 March 2021 2,294 3 View
As we know many journals are posting preprints (DOI) in advance before the peer-review process. However, there is no guarantee that the preprints get published. The journal's reviewers undergo the...
01 March 2021 5,778 2 View