The terminology in this question is taken from "Algebraic Topology" by CRF Maunder. See Problem 9 on Page 59.

"Let H be the abstract 1-dimensional simplicial complex with vertices a0, a1, a2, a3, a4, a5, each pair of vertices being an abstract 1-simplex. Show H has no realization in R2."

Note that I have added a5 to the author's text.

The reason I ask is this. We have the guitar tuning as the union of 6 string intervals defined by a 6-tuple representing a point such as (0, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5) or EADGBE, so each string is itself a 1-simplex.  Note that because each tuning interval is already defined on the system fundamental the secondary string spectrum is already inside the system fundamental spectrum.  When the strings are subsets of the system fundamental we say the guitar is "in tune".

If the vertices are the fundamentals of six guitar strings and the each string is defined by an interval between the fundamental state of system and the string, so the interval is always a known as a whole prime number defined on the system fundamental, then does not the solution to the above problem show that guitar music cannot be realized in R2?

I would like to prove in general the structure of music is 3-fold and not 2-fold as Euler thought.

More Terence B Allen's questions See All
Similar questions and discussions