This is the basic idea, we imagine the chance set up in our world, say a coin that is flipped, which has some chance for the outcome A, where A here could be 'the coin lands heads up'. Lets say for example that the probability for A is 50 percent: we call this, P(A)=0.5. What this means, is that some digit from an equi-distributed sequence modulo 1, for example L= {0.1,0.2,0.3, 0.4 0.5......1, 0.11,0.12.13,.14...} is randomly selected and assigned to coin flip . If the digit, Li, selected from L, is less than P(A), then A occurs. In other words, if the number Li that is part of L (and is selected randomly from the ) sequence L is smaller then 0.5, then A occurs (the coin lands heads up) otherwise ~A is the case (it lands tails).  Any given digit is possible, so the set up is in-deterministic, but I do not presume a measure over these digits, just that all of the digits are in the sample space (any given one could be selected).

If I presumed a measure, my account would be circular. What is important is that this means that on the single case, if A occurs; then if (hypothetically)P(A) were higher then what it was, A still would have occurred. (because then  P(A) would equal some number bigger than 0.5, for example, 0.6, and the digits of L which are smaller then 0.6 are a superset of the digits in L which are smaller than 0.5, so if we know that A occurred withP(A)=0.5, we know that the digit selected was smaller than 0.5, in which case we know that it is smaller than 0.6, and any event A, such that P(A)=0.6, is such that it occurs if the digit is smaller than 0.6.

In any case imagine we have an infinite number of these set ups, coins that is, each with the same chance for A, 'heads up'. I could use the language of possible worlds, but to get the point across we can imagine instead that this infinite number of coin flips occur at the same moment of time but at different points in space. Now suppose  this: The selection mechanism which determines the value Li (ie the digit selected from L) for any given coin flip, also determines the values of Li for all of the other coin flips, and it does so by determining their order at the same time (so we resolve the ordering problem as well, because how the sequence is ordered, determines which coin flip gets which result). Suppose there are as many coins as there are number in L, and that each coin will get one of the values of L, and there is an exact 1-1 mapping so that for every number in L, there is one (and only one) coin which gets that number.

So let us say the coins are initially, prior to any outcome occurring, ordered according to their spatial position at time t, M=[coin1 at position x=0, coin 2 at position x=1, coin 3 at position x=3 .......] for an infinite number of coins. Now when each and every coin gets mapped to one and only one digit, this is random, and this same random process re-arranges the coins in the sequence according to which digit they get, ie if a coin gets the second digit in L, then that coin occupies the second position in the new sequence; let us call this new sequence O.

The new sequence, O is always ordered so that the ith member of it (that is of O) always corresponds to the ith member of L. The first coin in the new sequence, O, gets the first member of L, which is 0.1, the second coin in this ordering, O gets the second digit of L, which as we can see is 0.2. Now it might be the 100th coin in the original sequence M becomes the first coin in this new sequence O , in which case it will occupy the first position in this new sequence, O, and will get the digit 0.1 and its outcome will be A as 0.1

More William Balthes's questions See All
Similar questions and discussions