Taking the example of Au/Pd metal, the ECSA is calculated from the Au/Pd-reduction curve carried out in 0.1M HCLO4/H2SO4 as per many reports in the literature (ref. below). When the ECSA is divided to the current obtained from the alcohol oxidation/H+ reduction by the modified electrode, the oxidation current becomes high (with a low ECSA number) and the oxidation current becomes low (when the ECSA is high). So, in this process how to infer which is a better electrocatalyst?
Eg. In this paper the ECSA is very low (0.0016 cc) with a high current density for hydrogen reduction.