Yes, you can reuse the wells of an ELISA plate that have not been exposed to air or to any of your reagents. Next time you purchase your plates, buy those with removable wells so that you can take only the wells that you need to use and leave those that you don't need in the package.
You can see how they look on this website: https://www.stellarscientific.com/nest-scientific-high-binding-elisa-plates-detachable-wells-5-pk-50-cs/?gclid=Cj0KCQjw_r3nBRDxARIsAJljleH0UD26XFpkPlfobLeMLlLTKKf1S6IvOpmsPuWsjM0JUOlrSbsf56saAlDWEALw_wcB