Suppose we dry the particles in a fixed bed or fluidized bed. If a particle of bulk material remains inside the apparatus, then the velocity of gas flow around the particle does not exceed the settling velocity. We can say it differently: we will have a flow velocity that fluctuates around the settling velocity for any superficial gas velocity. These fluctuations are precisely ensured by fluctuations in porosity during fluidization. Then in a fixed bed at the limit of its stability (before fluidization) Re will be approximately the same as during fluidization. The question is: from the point of view of energy consumption, can be fixed bed more efficient in some range of velocities(Re are comparable, and air consumption is less)?
Hey there Andrey Mitrofanov! Let me dive into that for you Andrey Mitrofanov. Now, fixed beds and fluidized beds each have their own set of merits and demerits, and the choice between them often boils down to specific process requirements.
In the scenario you've described, where the flow velocity fluctuates around the settling velocity for any superficial gas velocity in a fluidized bed, it's crucial to consider the energy consumption aspect. While the Reynolds number (Re) may be comparable between a fixed bed at its stability limit and a fluidized bed, energy efficiency hinges on various factors.
In some cases, a fixed bed might indeed exhibit lower air consumption due to the stable nature of the bed before fluidization. The absence of the dynamic fluctuations seen in fluidized beds could potentially contribute to reduced energy consumption.
However, the efficiency of either system depends on the specific conditions of the process, particle characteristics, and overall system design. It's not a one-size-fits-all situation. To give a more concrete answer, I'd need additional details about your specific application, such as particle size, material properties, and any other relevant parameters.
Feel free to provide more specifics, and I'll continue to assist you Andrey Mitrofanov.
A particle's terminal velocity is the lowest gas velocity that causes particles to start moving with the gas. This is the point at which entrainment begins. fluidization, the values of Pep are much higher than the corresponding ones for packed beds (2 −10 times) for the same value of Rep, covering the range 0.004 −0.06 for 0.4 < Rep
In general the choice of a fixed bed or a fluid bed dryer is based on the nature of the material to be dried. The quantity to be dried may indicate if a batch or continuous dryer is appropriate. Once this choice is made the chosen equipment can be made to be more energy efficient.
In other words, first select the equipment and then attempt energy efficiency.
Let me give an example: If you have a small quantity of fairly large sized non porous solid first carry out lab scale batch drying to check out on rate of drying, critical moisture content etc. The small throughput along with the large particle size distribution may suggest a fixed bed dryer ( like a tray dryer) and the superficial gas velocity may be chosen based on drying curve. The availability and cost of utility will dictate the inlet gas temperature to the dryer. The exhaust temperature will vary and gradually increase as the drying proceeds. As far energy efficiency, the specific numbers will indicate if a simple recirculation of exhaust gas with reheat is economical as opposed to once through.
For the same solid, if the throughput rate is very large, then a rotary dryer may be appropriate. Here too the possibility of recycle of exhaust gas remains depending on economic evaluation.
Now a fluid bed dryer is recommended only when the material to be dried is of such a nature that it is nicely fluidizable and not powdery. Eg carefully synthesized supported catalysts. Here too the exhaust gas can be recirculated to improve energy efficiency.
summarizing: first choose type of equipment depending on nature of material and then incorporate energy recovery features.
The choice between fixed-bed and fluidized-bed reactors is influenced by factors like cost, efficiency, and catalyst life. Fixed-bed reactors generally exhibit lower gas velocities, while fluidized-bed reactors operate at higher gas velocities. The Reynolds number undergoes a transition as fluidization occurs, changing from a constant value at the stability limit before fluidization. During fluidization, porosity variations contribute to dynamic flow characteristics, causing the flow velocity to oscillate around the settling velocity for any superficial gas velocity
- Badges
- Science topic