We both have deficient S content by using co-sputtering with WS2 and graphite targets and reactive sputtering with WS2 target and acetylene gas. Do you know how to resolve this problem, yes the literature indicated that this may be caused by bombardment of argon and reactions of Hydrogen and S to H2S, which consumes S content, however we tried many experiments with different parameters, the S/W ratio is mostly below 1. Looking forward to your warmhearted replies. Great thanks.