It is evident that ecotypes (provenances or populations) of grassland species react differently under climatic extremes. Genetic differences, local adaptation or past climatic experiences are often put forward to explain within-species variation. However, there is a substantial lack of experimental evidence regarding how long genetic variation (if it is the product of strong climatic adaptation) or local adaptation effects exist if ecotypes are planted in the same environment. This information is necessary to determine whether within-species diversity can effectively buffer against declining species richness or provide insurance against changing grasslands ecosystem functions in a changing climate.