I am looking for studies about expert blind spot hypothesis particularly in science. Also I am wondering if someone has researched expert blind spot hypothesis in peer tutoring?
Christoph, I can intuit what you are talking about, but I've never heard it named as such. Can you provide an initial citation for the concept? Is this similar to the "file drawer" problem (in which findings that are not statistically significant or don't fit clearly into the contemporary literature in some way don't get published)? Or is it something else?
I recall reading a (technical?) report on something called the 'expert blind spot' some time ago. It looked at the clash between expert knowledge and pedagogical content knowledge (as in Shulman's work). As I recall it was reporting that people with expertise in a particular discipline prefer to arrange the teaching of that knowledge according to the structure of the discipline than the needs of the learner. Though I think this report was on mathematics rather than science. I know it was an American study, but at the moment cannot recall which university. I may have it buried in my reference database and will try and look it up later. That said, is this the hypothesis you mean?
James, thank you, that is exactly what I mean. I know studies about this topic in the domain of mathematics, but not in science, which is my field of research - that is why I asked. However, I am still interested in the technical report you are talking about.
One of the reasons I am interested in the expert blind spot hypothesis is that this seems to be one of the very rare examples where the interdependence of two cognitive constructs is analyzed in a more elaborated way than just globally, like construct B globally benefits from construct A. Content knowledge might support pedagogical content knowledge and even teaching quality to a certain point - but too much content knowledge could even have a negative impact.
I've had a look in my reference database and I have one citation and one online pdf (which is the technical report, attached):
1. Mitchell J. Nathan and Anthony Petrosino
Expert Blind Spot Among Preservice Teachers American Educational Research Journal December 21, 2003 40: 905-928, doi:10.3102/00028312040004905
Article Expert Blind Spot Among Preservice Teachers
I am surprised at how many studies there are out there. My brother is a math teacher, so he deals with it a lot. I had not heard the term used in the social studies before. PDF]Expert Blind Spot: When Content Knowledge and ...
www.colorado.edu/ics/node/.../attachmen...
University of Colorado Boulder
We term this phenomenon expert blind spot and use historical, psychological, and ..... education, providing further support for expert blind spot hypothesis that.
[PDF]Expert Blind Spot: When Content Knowledge ... - PACT
pact.cs.cmu.edu/.../2001_NathanEtAl_ICCS_...
Carnegie Mellon University
by MJ Nathan - Cited by 36 - Related articles
We consider two arenas for expert blind spot (EBS) – areas where, because .... Additional evidence for the EBS Hypothesis comes from Grossman's (1990).
Expert Blind Spot Among Preservice Teachers
aer.sagepub.com/content/40/4/905.short
Sage Publications
by MJ Nathan - 2003 - Cited by 155 - Related articles
Dec 21, 2003 - As predicted by the “expert blind spot” hypothesis, participants with more advanced mathematics education, regardless of their program ...
[PDF]Expert Blind Spot Among Preservice Teachers - Network ...
website.education...
University of Wisconsin–Madison School of Education
by A Petrosino - 2003 - Cited by 155 - Related articles
In this article we investigate the “expert blind spot” hypothesis—the claim that ... The “blind spot” metaphor draws on past research in visual percep- tion that ...
Knowledge Transfer & The Expert Blind Spot - The ...
theknowledgetransfercompany.typepad.com/.../the-expert-blind-spot.ht...
Jul 22, 2011 - This is called the expert blind spot. Four ways to address your expert blind spot and three shortcomings experts make in formal presentations.
[PDF]EXPERT BLIND SPOT 1 Expert Blind Spot ... - CiteSeer
citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.129.886...
by MJ Nathan - Cited by 4 - Related articles
Expert Blind Spot Among Pre-Service Mathematics and Science Teachers .... the expert blind spot hypothesis – the claim that well-developed subject matter ...
Can anyone suggest any recent studies about the expert ...
www.researchgate.net/.../Can_anyone_suggest_any_recent_st...ResearchGate
4 days ago - I am looking for studies about expert blind spot hypothesis particularly in science. Also I am wondering if someone has researched expert blind ...
Are there any recent studies about expert blind spot ...
www.researchgate.net/.../Are_there_any_recent_studies_about...ResearchGate
5 days ago - I am looking for studies about expert blind spot hypothesis particularly in science. Also I am wondering if someone researched expert blind spot ...
Research - The College of Education
www.edb.utexas.edu/petrosino/.../research.h...
University of Texas at Austin
As predicted by the expert blind spot hypothesis, participants with more advanced mathematics education, regardless of their program affiliation or teaching ...
Thanks for the speedy explication of this topic. How might we specifically describe the hypothesis _as a hypothesis_? Might it be:
Expert cognitive knowledge can prevent the explication of new hypotheses outside of the domain of previously extant hypotheses.
???
This ends up, I think, being a question of social epistemology (what is understood to be knowledge) as much as anything.
Blind spots in ecosystem services research and implementation
http://biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2015/12/02/033498.full.pdf
In string theory they have use , 1+2+3+4......all the way to inf =-1/12 . i think that is best kept secret in physics and kind of a blind spot to me
pauli exclusive principle.in exclusive principle aduptaion of quantum states simultaniusly is shok me . Because there is no such a thing like simultaneous in (STR). Other hand how can be both theory have different judgement in same pace time?
or Any thing can be encapsulated in to theory as we keep condensed set of Observation?