It can not be Al even though the diffraction patterns are coming in the same range as Al. The intensity of Al's patterns is totally opposite to this. You may have to match the library data to get the exact match. It's really hard to tell bey looking at the patterns.
In case you know that only Al or Al2O3 can be the phase, and the radiation is Cu, then it is definitely Al. The different intensities can be easily interpreted by an existing cube texture caused by the processing of the sample.
In case you are asking why... There is a small but still effective software called PowerCell which enables the simulation of diffraction patterns within tens of seconds... You can download is here from Researchgate.
Hi, a better option than the ftp link (thanks V. Sidey) is https://www.researchgate.net/project/PowderCell-a-useful-tool-for-crystallographers-mineralogists-and-materials-scientists
The reason I do not exactly know which version is downloadable via ftp. Moreover, the link also contains a description which might be useful in case you want know more about the background equations and procedures used in PowderCell.