Anti-freezing hydrogel using ethylene glycol becomes sticky to remove it from mold and does not have proper shape?

my suggestion is as below which can be wrong but might be helpful.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

It’s a common and frustrating problem when modifying hydrogel formulations. The stickiness, difficulty in demolding, and poor shape retention you’re experiencing are all symptoms pointing to a few key issues, primarily related to how ethylene glycol (EG) interacts with your hydrogel polymerization process.

Based on your description, the high concentration of ethylene glycol (30% by volume) in your precursor solution is the most likely culprit. Let’s dive deep into why this is happening and explore several effective solutions to get you a well-formed, non-sticky, anti-freezing hydrogel.

Why is This Happening? A Detailed Breakdown

Adding a polyol like ethylene glycol fundamentally changes the environment in which your hydrogel network forms. While it’s excellent for preventing freezing, it can interfere with the polymerization and cross-linking reactions in several ways:

Interference with Polymerization Kinetics:Increased Viscosity: Your precursor solution of 30% EG is significantly more viscous than pure water. This slows down the diffusion of all components, including the initiator radicals and monomers. This can lead to a slower, less efficient, and incomplete polymerization reaction. Chain Transfer: Ethylene glycol, like other alcohols, can act as a chain-transfer agent in free-radical polymerization. A growing polymer chain, instead of adding another monomer, might abstract a hydrogen atom from an ethylene glycol molecule. This terminates the growing chain and creates a new radical on the EG molecule. The result is a larger number of shorter polymer chains, leading to a lower overall molecular weight and a weaker, less-defined network structure. The final product is more like a sticky “goo” than a robust, elastic gel. Initiator Efficiency: The solvent composition can affect the solubility and decomposition rate of your initiator (e.g., ammonium persulfate (APS)). If the initiator is less effective in the EG/water mixture, fewer primary radicals are generated, leading to an incomplete reaction.

Incomplete or Inefficient Cross-linking:This is the most direct cause of a sticky gel that doesn’t hold its shape. A hydrogel’s solid-like properties come from a three-dimensional network of polymer chains held together by cross-links. If the polymerization is inefficient (due to the reasons above), or if the cross-linker itself is hindered, you don’t form a complete network. The result is a gel with many “dangling” polymer chains that are not integrated into the network, contributing to surface stickiness.

Increased Adhesion to the Mold:Ethylene glycol is a “sticky” molecule itself and alters the surface tension of the solution. This can dramatically increase the adhesion of the hydrogel precursor and the final gel to the mold surface, especially if you are using hydrophilic molds like glass or many common plastics. When you try to remove the weak, sticky gel from a surface it strongly adheres to, it will tear and leave residue, failing to retain its shape.

Actionable Solutions and Troubleshooting Strategies

Here is a comprehensive list of strategies, from simple tweaks to more advanced chemical methods, to solve your problem.

Strategy 1: Optimize Your Formulation (Easiest to Try)

Before changing your entire process, simple adjustments to your recipe can often solve the problem.

Increase Cross-linker and Initiator Concentration: This is the most direct way to counteract the inhibiting effects of ethylene glycol. A weak network is often a sign of insufficient cross-linking or initiation.Recommendation: Systematically increase the concentration of your cross-linker (e.g., MBAA) by 25%, 50%, and then 100% relative to your original recipe. Do the same for your initiator (e.g., APS/TEMED). This forces the formation of a more densely cross-linked and robust network, which will be less sticky and mechanically stronger.
Try Glycerol Instead: You mentioned glycerol as another option. Glycerol is also an excellent cryoprotectant. It is more viscous than EG and has three hydroxyl groups, which might make it behave differently as a chain transfer agent. Sometimes, simply swapping one polyol for another can solve the issue.Recommendation: Prepare a similar formulation but replace the 3ml of ethylene glycol with 3ml of glycerol and observe the difference.

Strategy 2: Improve the Demolding Process

A proper mold and surface preparation can make a world of difference, even with a slightly sticky gel.

Use a Hydrophobic Mold: The best choice for casting hydrogels is a material to which they won’t stick.Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE / Teflon): This is the gold standard. Hydrogels rarely stick to PTFE. If you can machine or find a PTFE mold, it will likely solve your demolding issue. Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS): PDMS is also hydrophobic and commonly used. It’s flexible, which helps in peeling the gel out. However, be aware that some organic solvents can cause PDMS to swell over time.
Treat Your Mold Surface: If you must use a glass or plastic mold, you can make its surface hydrophobic.Silanization (The Lab Method): Treating a glass surface with a silane coupling agent creates a permanent, low-energy, hydrophobic layer. A common agent is Trichloro(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorooctyl)silane. This requires proper safety precautions (fume hood). The Practical Hack (Rain-X or Aquapel): Automotive windshield water repellents work on the same principle. They are easy to apply to glass molds and create an effective release surface.Clean and dry your glass mold thoroughly. Apply a small amount of Rain-X with a cloth. Let it haze over for a few minutes. Buff it off with a clean, dry cloth until the surface is clear. Your mold is now highly hydrophobic.

Strategy 3: Modify the Synthesis Protocol (Most Effective Method)

This approach, known as post-synthesis solvent exchange, separates the polymerization from the introduction of the anti-freeze agent. This allows you to form a perfect hydrogel network first, then make it anti-freezing. This technique is referenced in literature (as seen in search result 3) and is extremely effective.

The Protocol:

Synthesize in Pure Water: Prepare your hydrogel precursor solution without any ethylene glycol. Use only deionized water as the solvent. This allows the polymerization and cross-linking to proceed under ideal conditions, forming a robust, non-sticky, perfectly shaped hydrogel.

Polymerize and Cure: Let the polymerization complete fully in the mold.

Demold: Since the hydrogel was made in water, it will be much less sticky and easier to remove from the mold, especially if you followed the mold preparation tips in Strategy 2.

Solvent Exchange: Prepare your target anti-freezing solution (e.g., a 30% v/v ethylene glycol / 70% water mixture). Submerge your fully formed hydrogel in this solution.

Equilibrate: Leave the hydrogel in the EG/water bath. Over time, the EG molecules will diffuse into the hydrogel network, and some water will diffuse out, until the solvent composition inside the hydrogel is the same as the surrounding bath. This process usually takes 24-48 hours, depending on the thickness of your gel. You can gently agitate the bath to speed it up.

Why this works: You get the best of both worlds: a perfectly formed network structure and the desired anti-freezing properties, without one process interfering with the other.

Recommended Step-by-Step Approach for Your Next Experiment

Prepare a hydrophobic mold: Get a PTFE mold or treat your current glass/plastic mold with Rain-X as described above. This is a simple step that removes a major variable.

Attempt the Solvent Exchange Method (Strategy 3):Prepare your precursor solution using 10 mL of deionized water (instead of 7mL water + 3mL EG). Keep all monomer, cross-linker, and initiator concentrations the same as your original recipe. Degas the solution (important for removing oxygen, which inhibits polymerization). Pour into your prepared mold and polymerize. Once cured, carefully demold your hydrogel. It should be much stronger and less sticky. Immerse this hydrogel in a bath of 30% ethylene glycol / 70% water for 24-48 hours.

If you must polymerize in EG: If for some reason you cannot use solvent exchange, try Strategy 1.Go back to your original 3mL EG / 7mL water precursor. Double the concentration of your cross-linker and see if that forms a better gel. If it’s still weak, also try increasing the initiator.

By following these steps, you should be able to successfully fabricate a well-defined, easy-to-handle, anti-freezing hydrogel. The solvent exchange method is the most robust and scientifically sound approach to solving this specific problem.

Do you think can be any Uranium bearing rocks in Eastern part of Iran and western part of Afghanistan?

Do you think can be any diamond bearing rocks in Eastern part of Iran and western part of Afghanistan?

What is the difference between mathematical R^4 space and physical 4D unit space?

If Banks do not provide credit facility, what are the options available for FPOs and impact on producer’s income?

Controlling for pupil light reflex when analyzing pupil size time course?

What are a “Farmers Producer Organization” (FPO) and its essential features?

Strugglling with m6A dot blot any suugesstion ?

Do interactions between biosphere, carbon cycle, & water cycle impact global warming & interaction between atmosphere & hydrosphere?

How to get moment output in Abaqus Standart?

How is energy cycled through the Earth's climate system and how do matter cycle and energy flow through the rock cycle?

Ethylene glycol is newtonian or non newtonian fluid?

How to check pH of a high strength hydrogel?

Does anybody know why my chitosan/pva/gelatin hydrogel dissolve in PBS?

How are clinical and environmental yeast/fungal strains stored usually in mycology laboratories?

Guidance needed for preparing the hydrogel samples for the XRD instrument?

immunofluorescence, False Positive Nuclear Staining in Hydrogel-Embedded Breast Cells?

Glycerol/serinol hplc separation?

Cell Count Imaging of Hydrogel Inside Inserts?

How to prepared Laemnili buffer 5x?

Why is there no peak shifting in FTIR-ATR after the adsorption of PS-NH2 onto the NIPAAM/CMC hydrogel materials?