Since quality of water results by the contributions of all types parameters present in water, it would be more effective as well as authentic to use all of them to estimate water quality index.
As per earlier discussion this question suggests that all the parameters have to be considered but in weighated arithmatic method as the number of parameters increased it increases the final value and possibility to turn out all good quality samples into bad one. So, to avoid this confusion you can adopt the newly developed unbiased and easy Intergrated water quality index.