Hi everyone~
I’m working on selecting microorganisms that degrade lignin present in pulp and paper wastewater. I am trying various methods to quantify lignin according to the references, but I’m having difficulties with reproducibility and unexpected results.
[Exp. Condition]
- In order to check whether there are microorganisms that selectively decompose only lignin, a medium mixed with M9 medium and Lignin alkali (CAS 8068-05-1) 3~7g/L was prepared. However, a precipitate was formed immediately after the medium was prepared (adjust as pH 7.5). Approximately 40-50% of the input weight is measured as VSS (1.2um pore filter paper).
- Seeding Microorganisms: Microorganisms taken from on-site aeration tanks also contain a lot of solids and lignin
- In the future, I plan to apply the same lignin quantifying method to the wastewater of the pulp and paper plant.
- Due to the small amount of microbial culture sampling, it was impossible to use only solids by drying a large amount of wastewater. (maximum 10ml for lignin measurement)
[The methods and problems that have been tried so far are as follows]
Standard method (American Public Health Association) 5550 TANNIN and LIGNIN --> The above methodology was unsuitable because it measures aromatic hydroxyl groups, causing false positive errors with hydroxylated aromatics and sugars present in wastewater, and cannot be quantified for solids.UV/vis 430nm method --> Only dissolved lignin can be measured, So I determined that it cannot be used.Klason method (modified) --> Based on the references below (Ref 1~3), it has been modified to include personal views. Please refer to the attached figure for the methodology of Trial-1 and 2.- In Trial-1, high weight was measured up to 200-800% of the input lignin, and the measurement result was not constant. (During filtration, the black liquid sometimes flows down and sometimes a transparent solution is obtained.)
- I suspected that carbonization occurs by reacting with sulfuric acid during digestion, or salt generation during drying can cause some problems. So I modified the method more (trial-2)
- In Trial-2, 10% lower lignin concentration was measured in the experimental group, and it looks like I got the reproducible (constant) result.
- Unbelievably, M9 medium without lignin also shows 'containing lignin results'…. M9 media with seed (1% V/V) shows the same or more lignin content than M9+seed+7g lignin Exp. Group.
- Results what I got is: M9 only >= M9+seed (1%) >= M9+7g lignin+ seed (1%) > M9 + 3g lignin + seed (1%)
[Questions]
Are there any errors in the experimental method?Are there any other analytical methods (which can measure both solids and dissolved lignin at the same time)?* The acetyl bromide method in Ref 4. is difficult to use due to the limitations of laboratory equipment.
[Ref.]
Reyes-Rivera, J., & Terrazas, T. (2017). Lignin Analysis by HPLC and FTIR. Methods in Molecular Biology , 1544, 193–211. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-6722-3_14Andeme Ela, R. C., Spahn, L., Safaie, N., Ferrier, R. C., & Ong, R. G. (2020). Understanding the Effect of Precipitation Process Variables on Hardwood Lignin Characteristics and Recovery from Black Liquor. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 8(37), 13997–14005. https://doi.org/10.1021/acssuschemeng.0c03692Aldaeus, F., Schweinebarth, H., Törngren, P., & Jacobs, A. (2011). Simplified determination of total lignin content in kraft lignin samples and black liquors. Holzforschung, 65(4). https://doi.org/10.1515/hf.2011.102Moreira-Vilar, F. C., Siqueira-Soares, R. D. C., Finger-Teixeira, A., Oliveira, D. M. D., Ferro, A. P., da Rocha, G. J., ... & Ferrarese-Filho, O. (2014). The acetyl bromide method is faster, simpler and presents best recovery of lignin in different herbaceous tissues than Klason and thioglycolic acid methods. PloS one, 9(10), e110000.Thank you for your interest and advice
Best regards - Sang Hyeok