In order to maintain research integrity, plagiarism has to be given up. However, many people do not know they are committing plagiarism intentionally or unintentionally. How we can be more concerned about this issue?
Vijay had plagiarised the above from http://gethelp.library.upenn.edu/guides/engineering/ee/plagiarize.html ! It has now been removed by the Plagiarism Police.
Vijay had plagiarised the above from http://gethelp.library.upenn.edu/guides/engineering/ee/plagiarize.html ! It has now been removed by the Plagiarism Police.
I think it all comes down to personal integrity and honesty.. If i want to write an original paper, then i will have to work hard and not rely on copy-shake-past from other authors' work...
Yes, agree that its a big problem in the copy and paste era. Experienced teachers and peers can help in controlling the plagiarism as they can easily detect from the style and depth of the knowledge.
@Ian: i also use google for checking plagiarism on some of the student assignments.. i usually paste a paragraph in search and although not as sophisticated as turnitin etc. at least it can tell if something is simply copy-pasted from another online source or not...
Can we propose to the computer industry to leverage technology by incorporating a meta tag into the copy and paste function that ensures that anything copied and pasted remembers where it was copied and pasted from?
@Maria. It does not check journals, but I recommend it as a first line of defense. I am putting my book through it, bit by bit to make sure I have not let anything slip through.
It is quite clever, in that it seems to submit the end of one sentence with the beginning of next. We could try the same trick with Scholar and Pubmed.
With the means proposed so far, you can only uncover plagiarism but not prevent it. You need a culture of anti-plagiarism in your community (academic and/or regional). As of today, there have been more than five high-ranking members of German governments (Federal and State) been convicted of plagiarism when writing down their doctoral theses. They were removed from office or stepped down because of public pressure, among them were the (1) Federal Defence Minister and the (2) Minister of Research and Technology (yes, she herself!). Currently under scrutiny is the (3) speaker of the Parliament (Bundestag), and all is being intensely followed by the public. Number (2) and (3) had written their theses before the Internet age, when it was quite difficult to spot plagiarism, but with today's tools - thanks, Ian and others, for laying them out to us - it can be a worthwhile effort to find results of such misconduct.
@Ian, You had suggested PubMed ! It is for bioemedical field primarily. Schoolar is widely known for all fields! Since You are well informed in this field, can You suggest some more , widely used web services for checking the plagiarism? Thanks in advance.
@Maria Maldonado Garcia suggested good service (Small SEO Tools) :)
@Michael: Do not think that your country holds the monopoly on plagiarism!
@Ljubomir: Use the full text search facility of the journals in your field. Start with IEEE Xplore. Give it suspiciously well formed phrases from your student's work. Do not pay for any commercial services. They give you a false sense of security, based on inadequate databases. For example, they do not index IEEE.
@Maria: Click on the links to find what is happening. You will probably find that the names of your helpers are common names in your field (and they are not in quotes!). It will be more instructive for you to check your Introduction for phrases you have stolen from the Web.
Remember that SmallSEOTools is intended for Webmasters, not researchers, so it is only of use in looking for your lazy student plagiarisers.
@The Plagiarist: Find an old dusty book to plagiarise from!
@Maria: You really do not expect anybody to have put your thesis on the Web do you?
SmallSeoTools checker builds up from 0% original content (case unproven) to hopefully 100% original (Web) content. If I give it the original question at the top of this posting, it reports only 25% original content (the incorrect space comma) BECAUSE IT FINDS THIS QUESTION ON RG!
It is not a plagiarism checker because it does not look to see if you have given the citation and whether you have given the citation correctly
and does not look at journals and books. It is just a useful little tool incorporating a useful little technique for catching out lazy students (and bad WebMasters).
@Maria: scholar.google.com has no built-in plagiarism checker. You have to feed it with suspect sentences. My suggestion was to feed it with half of one sentence and half of the next at a time. E.g. to check for copying of this very post of mine, give it: "feed it with suspect sentences. My suggestion was" (When I tried it, nothing was found, as I expected, because I had just composed that sentence pair, and they are not in any paper!). Do not send all your text. Just send stuff that feels suspicious.
@Vahid: Thank you for not plagiarising. Sadly, however, your source is wrong and misleading!
-Paraphrasing will NOT avoid plagiarism. You have still to cite any material that you paraphrase.
-Citing: This is simply the ONLY way to avoid plagiarism, and is the correct answer to Mohammad's original question.
-Citing paraphrases: This is NO different to citing quotes. Why should there be any difference? Where page numbers are available, they should always be given so that the source can be verified quickly.
Many tools are available to check plagarism, one of them is http://smallseotools.com/plagiarism-checker/ ,which is freely available. Content must be well tested before publication and should create awareness in students about it.
Watch out for any sudden change of style, formatting, tone, voice, language ability or grammar in your student's work. Follow all the purported references in their work.
I think one should educate researchers, co-authors and students about Plagiarism, what it is and the dangers therof. Also, how to avoid plagiarism. It's really easy to give credit to the original authors in one's text, so plagiarism is completely unnecessary.
In my papers / presentation / proposals, I make reference to many works of other people - it gives added credibility to what I have to say (I've done my homework and researched the topic) and there is no need to copy someone else's work and claim it's your own. Personally I think it's probably the same amount of work to give the original author credit that it is to commit plagiarism.
It pretty much boils down to the author to choose to do the right thing, and authors need to hear this.
Google is a great help for understanding plagiarism. To me, most of these "thieves" don't even make the effort of changing the text enough, in order to bypass this simple test. If we talk about students, I agree with Ian Kennedy, style is a good indicator of original or "stolen" work...
I think the best way is to write in your own words and then ask help from professional writers or native speakers or even write in your own language and then translate the text.
The use of plagiarism detection software as a mean of self-control is also OK.
If some one is doing these Plagiarism continuosly then what would be the after effect of it??? How can we convince them that Plaigiarism is a crime... Is their any punishment for them...
When I was on a university plagiarism committee, I was surprised to learn that the University could even impose a fine on a plagiarising student, apart from subject failure, course failure or banishment.