Is it possible for the soil pH to be around 8, but with negligible amounts of carbonates, bicarbonates and exchangeable sodium?

Yes, it is possible for soil to have a pH around 8 with negligible amounts of carbonates, bicarbonates, and exchangeable sodium. Several factors can contribute to a high soil pH without the significant presence of these common alkaline components. Here's a detailed analysis of how this can happen and what might be influencing the soil pH:

Factors Affecting Soil pH

Soil Minerals and Parent Material:Silicate Minerals: Soils derived from parent materials rich in silicate minerals (such as basalt) can have a higher pH. Silicate weathering can consume hydrogen ions, leading to a more alkaline environment. Basic Cations: Presence of basic cations such as calcium (Ca²⁺), magnesium (Mg²⁺), and potassium (K⁺) can elevate soil pH. These cations can replace hydrogen ions (H⁺) on soil colloids, reducing soil acidity.

Soil Organic Matter:Humic Substances: High levels of organic matter can buffer pH changes. Humic and fulvic acids can complex with metal ions, which might contribute to a neutral to slightly alkaline pH. Decomposition: The decomposition of organic matter can release basic cations, which can neutralize acidity and raise pH.

Irrigation Water:Alkaline Water: If irrigation water has a high pH or contains dissolved basic cations, it can influence soil pH over time. This can occur even if the soil itself has negligible carbonates and bicarbonates. Water Quality: Regular use of water with low bicarbonate and carbonate but high pH can gradually increase soil pH.

Fertilizers and Soil Amendments:Lime Application: Even if carbonate and bicarbonate levels are low now, previous lime applications (calcium carbonate, CaCO₃) can have lasting effects on soil pH. Gypsum (Calcium Sulfate): Application of gypsum can displace sodium ions without significantly altering carbonate and bicarbonate levels, potentially increasing soil pH.

Environmental Conditions:Arid and Semi-Arid Climates: In these regions, evaporation exceeds precipitation, leading to the accumulation of soluble salts that can influence pH. Evapotranspiration: High rates of evapotranspiration can concentrate basic cations in the soil, contributing to a higher pH.

Steps to Confirm and Analyze Soil pH

Verify pH Measurement:Calibration: Ensure that the pH meter is properly calibrated using standard buffer solutions (pH 4, 7, and 10). Sample Preparation: Ensure that the soil sample is prepared correctly, typically by mixing soil with distilled water in a 1:1 or 1:2 ratio and allowing it to equilibrate before measuring. Replicates: Conduct multiple measurements to confirm consistency and rule out measurement errors.

Test for Basic Cations:Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC): Measure the soil's CEC to understand the capacity to hold and exchange basic cations. Extractable Cations: Analyze soil for extractable calcium, magnesium, and potassium to see if they are contributing to the high pH.

Check for Residual Effects:Historical Land Use: Investigate past soil management practices, including lime or gypsum applications. Irrigation Water Quality: Analyze the pH and ion composition of irrigation water used in the area.

Examine Soil Mineralogy:X-Ray Diffraction (XRD): Conduct XRD analysis to identify the mineral composition of the soil, which might explain the source of alkalinity.

Organic Matter Analysis:Organic Carbon Content: Measure the soil organic carbon content to evaluate the potential influence of organic matter on soil pH. Humic Substances: Determine the content of humic and fulvic acids.

Conclusion

It is indeed possible for soil pH to be around 8 without significant carbonates, bicarbonates, or exchangeable sodium due to the presence of other basic cations, organic matter, and certain soil minerals. To confirm the source of the alkalinity, it is essential to verify your pH measurement procedure and conduct a comprehensive analysis of soil properties, including mineral composition, organic matter, and historical land management practices. This thorough approach will help you identify the factors contributing to the soil's high pH and rule out any potential errors in the analysis.

Abhishek Kumar

Yes, soil pH can reach approximately 8 in the absence of considerable levels of exchangeable sodium, bicarbonates, or carbonates. Many factors affect soil pH, but the main one is the amount of hydrogen ions (H+) in the soil solution. A soil pH of 8 denotes a somewhat alkaline state. A pH of 8 without significant levels of carbonates, bicarbonates, or exchangeable sodium could be caused by several factors: 1. Soil Buffering Capacity: A soil's ability to withstand pH fluctuations despite outside factors is attributed to its strong buffering capacity. This could keep the pH at or near 8 without having a noticeable amount of bicarbonates or carbonates. 2. Alkaline Salts: Although they are not carbonate or bicarbonate forms, other alkaline materials or salts in the soil, such as calcium hydroxide (lime), can nevertheless contribute to alkalinity. These substances can raise pH without directly raising carbonate levels. 3. Natural Alkalinity: Alkaline pH levels can occur naturally as a result of specific soil minerals and weathering processes. Soils originating from calcareous parent materials, such as limestone, may naturally possess an alkaline quality. 4. Lack of Exchangeable Sodium: By displacing calcium and magnesium ions from soil particles, exchangeable sodium ions can raise the pH in soils. The pH spike would have to be attributed to other sources if exchangeable sodium is negligible. Thus, provided other alkaline materials or soil properties are present, a pH of 8 can be maintained in soil without significant carbonates, bicarbonates, or exchangeable sodium. When evaluating soil pH levels, it's critical to take the particular soil composition and surrounding circumstances into account.

Has anyone tried to scan fluorescence IHC slides with microarray scanner?

What is recommended and opened real-time or nearly real time geospatial data used in flood risk assessment and regional planning on a detailed scale?

Different antibodies show signal at same MW in SDS-PAGE, what is wrong?

Do you consider that rose bengal chloramphenicol agar is suitable to isolate and count fungus?

No title

The modern system of international relations: unipolar or multipolar world?

Mie scattering of a Gaussian with curved wavefront by a sphere?

Blood and tissue DNeasy mini kit 260/230 contamination?

Regression analysis on small but complete dataset (perfect representation of reality)?

Student's t-test or DeSeq2 for RNA-Seq data analysis?

How to compare two groups with only two measurements?

Enhanced Yellow Fluorescent Protein (Aequorea victoria) DNA sequence?

What kind of fluid could I use for a pitfall trap that also does not invalidate molecular testing?

Does the pressure(-600 mmHg) affects pH?

What's the best way to measure growth rates in House sparrow chicks from day 2 to day 10?

Do we need to write protocol for a second study of a systematic review that has been registered and published?

How to increase a model accuracy ?

Chlorinated organic formation in odor control scrubbers using hypochlorite?

Do I need to do linear regression before running mediation analysis using PROCESS MACRO by Hayes ?

Sample dilution for quantitative analysis using ELISA?