Dear Colleagues,
I am currently working on genomic DNA extraction from mangrove soil using the NucleoSpin Soil Kit (Takara Bio), but I am facing issues with low DNA yield, No DNA on gel, no PCR product on gel and some unexpected observations during the extraction process. I would appreciate any insights, suggestions, or similar experiences from others working with high-salt soil samples.
Experimental Conditions & Observations
I tested the following conditions for DNA extraction (all using 40 µL elution):
- SL1 buffer → 5.7 ng/µL
- SL1 + 150 µL SX → 6.4 ng/µL
- SL2 buffer → 5.9 ng/µL
- SL2 + 150 µL SX → 9.8 ng/µL
Since the yields were low, I performed a second elution, and the results were:
- SL1 → 5.9 ng/µL
- SL1 + 150 µL SX → 6.9 ng/µL
- SL2 → 7.1 ng/µL
- SL2 + 150 µL SX → 7.1 ng/µL
I also pre-warmed SL1 and SL2 buffers at 37°C before use to avoid precipitation. Recently, I tested 40°C, but there was no significant improvement in yield.
Issues Encountered
Low DNA Yield & Gel ElectrophoresisThe overall yield is low even after a second elution. Running an agarose gel gave no visible bands. Possible reasons I am considering:High salt content in mangrove soil interfering with DNA binding. Insufficient lysis or inefficient elution. DNA loss during washing steps. Potential solutions I am considering: increasing elution volume or incubation time. I have also tried bead beeting for 2:00 min, then 30 sec break, then again 2:00 min bead beeting, then 30 sec break, then again 2:00 min bead beeting. Adding an extra wash step to remove inhibitors. Dripping During Step 8 (SW2 Wash Step)While vortexing with SW2, I noticed liquid dripping into the collection tube in all columns (drop-wise, not continuous). Could this indicate an issue with membrane retention, or is this expected? Request for Suggestions
- Has anyone optimized DNA extraction from high-salt soil samples like mangroves with NucleoSpin Soil Kit (Takara Bio)?
- Would using an alternative kit (e.g., DNeasy PowerSoil Kit, Zymo Quick-DNA Fecal/Soil Microbe Kit) improve results?
- Any additional steps (e.g., higher temperature lysis, ethanol wash modifications) that might improve yield?
- Has anyone tested methods to remove salt interference for silica column-based extractions?
I would greatly appreciate any suggestions, protocol optimizations, or experiences you can share. I am also attaching the protocol with this question.
Thank you in advance for your help!