Sometimes a lower wear under higher load can be explained because the particle debris are sintered back into one of the two bodies. This means that the detached wear debris literally reattach to the acting or counter-acting body due to the high load, basically what happens in the process of sintering powders to obtain solid objects. This happens easily with metals rather than ceramic but it my happen also with ceramics. a better description of your experiment and conditions would help in understanding if you are close to the plastic deformation loads.
@Elia: That could be due to the change of wear mechanism. What I have seen from SEM and AFM images, more grooves and ploughing are obvious in lower load.
@Enrico: Thank you. I have not seen any evidence of this behaviour so far. It might need further investigation.