Dear Colleagues> I have been asked to do revisions on a manuscript (submitted to a medical journal--not a brain imaging journal).
Here's the situation:The majority of our results were analyzed (using FSL Flame 1 ) at a cluster z= 2.3, p< 0.001, but we did include a subset of results analyzed with a cluster threshold of 1.65, p < 0.01. The particular journal is requesting a 3rd revision now, asking that we eliminate the results reported at the lower threshold.
The reason we included the lower threshold results is that they represent comparisons done between very similar conditions.
Trying to sort out whether it is acceptable ( in your opinion, by current standards) in fMRI publications to include some results at 1.65, p < 0.01?
Please email me at [email protected] if you have some suggestions. I am not sure how to access responses to questions here and we do have a bit of time pressure to decide our approach.
Thanks so much!
Nan