@ V. G. Rousseau

Hide this bloody cat somewhere in your .... and attend to the open challenge to the theory of relativity which is standing since 2012 as all the jockers on the name of physics failed to prove me incorrect. Justify the Lorentz factor in transverse Doppler effect and produce experimentally the contraction of space in the direction of motion both while the observer is approaching or receding the source. Only some nonsense person can do it in his dreams.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

I see... So, you are fleeing again like a coward because you can't point out a single wrong equation in my rigorous derivation. Keep running away!

V. G. Rousseau

The problem is you talk absolute nonsense and ResearchGate is demonstrating open bias against me. I don't have run away and I am born fighter for truth. The Einstein and everything based on his theory of relativity, including General Theory of Relativity, space-time concept, formula E=mc^2,;all are based on scientific fraud. Please see my paper "Rebuttal of papers of Lann N. Ramez......." wherein the fraud of Einstein has been exposed and you have nowhere to go. Try to challenge this Rebuttal and believe me I will drop the open challenge.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

This thread is about "Einstein's Cat", the thought experiment that debunks anti-relativist myths. Point out a single mathematical mistake in it, or get away!

V. G. Rousseau

This is the discussion forum I can't write 17 page research paper page on the ResearchGate discussion forum so read the Rebuttal paper and see for yourself that Einstein had used two different velocity of light in the different coordinates systems thereby violating the very postulate of constancy of velocity of light irrespective of motion of source and observer.

I repeat that if you can show me that my rebuttal paper is wrong I will drop the open challenge.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

I won't read your unpublished and and non-peer-reviewed propaganda.

Point out a single mathematical mistake in the video you are criticizing, or get away!

V.G.Roussea

I don't bother what you have, cat or rat. I have pointed out in the 1905 main paper of Einstein he has used two different velocities of light in two cordinate systems, one is consistent with his postulate of constancy of velocity of light irrespective of motion of the observer and the second is constant with respect to space wherein he uses c+v & c-v. Set this right then come up the nonsense you have. For complete details read the Rebuttal.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

"I have pointed out in the 1905 main paper of Einstein he has used two different velocities..."

This thread is not about Einstein's main paper, it is about a new thought experiment that is totally independent of any previous work since the video is entirely self-contained: https://youtu.be/PFh_OQMwKmU

V. G. Rousseau

I have no time for any nonsense favouring Einstein total contribution. There can be no rational, mathematical, theoretical and experimental justification for Einstein's perspective. If there is any experimental evidence of contraction of space in the direction of motion of the observer whether observer is receding or observer is approaching the source from 1905 till to date then mention that except muon half life which concerns the time dilation not space contraction. Come up with some sense since I am very busy person. My actual theory accepts time dilation but no space dilation whatsoever.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

Poor guy... 120 years of daily experiments prove you wrong!

@V G Rousseau

Poor guy thinks Einstein was right all these years despite the fact Einstein's fraud was exposed and when his theory of relativity was shown incorrect mathematically, experimentally and theoretically and open challenge was put forward in 2012 which is still standing despite the lapse of more than twelve years. It is an established that those who accepted the open challenge had to hide their face because all their teeth were broken by the rebuttals one example of which is available on ResearchGate as Rebuttal of Lann N. Remaz ........ Instead of wasting my time you should read this Rebuttal and realise that you were justifying the absolute nonsense of Einstein and you have wasted the time by studying the physics which was based on the fraud of Einstein. Poor guy.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

I know it hurts some people that one of the pillar of modern science is the fruit of a Jew. But just go see a psychiatrist to get help.

Poor guy thinks Einstein was right all these years despite the fact Einstein's fraud was exposed and when his theory of relativity was shown incorrect mathematically, experimentally and theoretically and open challenge was put forward in 2012 which is still standing despite the lapse of more than twelve years. It is an established that those who accepted the open challenge had to hide their face because all their teeth were broken by the rebuttals one example of which is available on ResearchGate as Rebuttal of Lann N. Remaz ........ Instead of wasting my time you should read this Rebuttal and realise that you were justifying the absolute nonsense of Einstein and you have wasted the time by studying the physics which was based on the fraud of Einstein. Poor nonsense guy.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

Poor anti-relativist (or anti-Einstein? What did he do to you?) guy ignores that he uses everyday electronic devices that could not exist without Quantum Field Theory, hence without Relativity.

Haha

All members of ResearchGate

LET THE WHOLE WORLD KNOW THIS

Quran is such a great and final word of Allah that the proof of its divinity and secrets of physical and biological sciences were in just one verse. Read the verse (41-53) which means "Soon We shall show Our signs in the space and what is in their selves and then they will realise that this (meaning Quran) is truth and is not this enough that your Sustainer has the knowledge of everything?" The first sign is in the discovery of existence of aether, the electric dipoles, in space done through the scientific research paper published in peer-reviewed journal titled 'Michelson-Morley Experiment; A Misconceived and Misinterpreted Experiment' which is available in Indian Journal of Science and Technology with website address www.indjst.org besides many scientific websites. As the consequence of the discovery of aether in space all the physical sciences would require change.

Second sign has been given the name of 'energy' as it is allegorically mentioned as 'light' in Quran and is shown to be the only alternative which can explain the phenomena of life like consciousness, instincts, gowth, cell function, self-repair of cells etc., and above all biological laws in the scientific and philosophical paper titled 'Theory of Origin and Phenomenon of Life' published in the same as above-mentioned journal. However the paper is being revised in the 'Revised Theory of Origin and Phenomenon of Life' which is under preparation. As the consequence of this paper the biological sciences would require the changes.

This should be the sufficient scientific proof of divinity of Quran and the existence of Allah as the Knower so Creator of everything in the universe.

Let the whole Muslim world celebrate this on coming 'night of Qadr'.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

And here is the related paper that was just released on arxiv.org: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.17248

I'll let you cry in peace (or perhaps in pieces, LOL).

Hahaha........... HaHaHa

Remember open challenge is still standing till today. Be sure it will be defended. A stupid foolish physicist like you named Lann N. Ramez accepted the open challenge and see his plight in my Rebuttal paper which is available in my profile. Have guts to accept the open challenge but don't write nonsense as you usually do because I don't have time to reply nonsense.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

Go see a psychiatrist, poor crackpot. He will give you medicines that will make you happier, and your family won't have to undergo your child-like temper tantrums anymore.

V. G. Rousseau

I know you are a stupid fellow but to the extent of insanity I did not know. Without knowing my perspective you think you have conquered the mountain. I don't deny time dilation but the quantum of dilation is actually different than predicted by theory of relativity and Doppler effect is the experimental evidence of my my time dilation. Show me a single experimental evidence of space contraction since 1905 till date which theory of relativity predicted. But don't quote nonsense of muon halflife which concerns time dilation.

Mohammad Shafiq Khan

"I don't deny time dilation"

Oh, now you concede that time dilation is a real thing... That's some progress!

V. G. Rousseau

Please let us behave like civilized scientists. It is not now it is about fifteen years back I have accepted the time dilation as you can see my publications date back to 2010 and it so important that the very forces of nature are dependent upon time dilation.

Paper has been updated: Preprint Einstein's Cat - A Thought Experiment Against Anti-Relativist Claims

Anti-relativists are gonna cry again!

Paper peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. Here is the associated video abstract: https://youtu.be/nxAPELzc8hc

Published version here: Article Einstein’s cat: a thought experiment on the universality of ...

Go ahead, anti-relativists, keep crying!