Usually psychotherapists prefer to develop a treatment "alone", disfavoring the intervention of another psychological therapist at the same time. But in complex cases with different problematics, the intervention of other experts may be useful, like in medicine (cardiac problems with cardiologists & self-immune with immunologists). For example, is a concurrent psychological treatment (different psychotherapists) advisable in cases of comorbidity of HIV, drug abuse, cognitive deterioration, personality disorder, psychosis, family conflicts, etc.?
Two personal thoughts:
1. Against the background of the literature the aspect of a particular psychotherapeutic school, (sub)discipline, procedure or technique is very often overestimated, and gave not infrequently reason to sometimes absurd disputes. With the important work of Klaus Grawe (and others) we know what works best in psychotherapy, and these principles are universal and apply for all psychotherapeutic procedures that claim to be effective. Having said this, one may also think about the therapeutic relationship/alliance if a "case" appears to be complex and/or complicated before applying a non-evidence-based combination/potpourri of different (psycho)therapeutic procedures in an attitude of aimless activism.
2. In disorder-oriented psychotherapy there is reason to think of a reasonable combination of different therapeutic approaches, e.g., in somatoform or pain disorders the combination of mind and body therapies, or the addition of, e.g., EMDR in PTSD. Nevertheless, the clinical Impression that these combination are often beneficial, there is a lack of well conducted research in the field...
My research pertained to Native American populations, so I can only speak to that right now. In the literature, there were some interesting articles which had to do with collaboration between traditional healers and therapies considered research based. These authors in particular and the dates of their publication are good sources: Belcourt-Dittloff & Belcourt, 2007; LaFromboise, 1988; Torres et al., 2005; Walls, Johnson, Whitbeck, & Hoyt, 2006. I hope this helps.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Medicine
- Counseling Psychology