Reject. Seed plants are definitely monophyletic, comprised of two major groups: gymnosperms and angiosperms. The evolutionary history of gymnosperms is a little muddled still, and most phylogenetic studies have provided little resolution, suggesting that gymnosperms may be paraphyletic. But angiosperms are monophyletic.
I don't know of any papers that address this topic directly, but as far as I know seed plants have been considered monophyletic for a while. The following two papers include phylogenetic trees, all of which indicate spermatophytes are monophyletic:
un groupe paraphylétique est un groupe artificiel. la découpe du groupe se fait horizontalement pour permettre son étude. on considère les spermaphytes comme une groupe monophylétique ( ancêtre commun et tous ses descendants.
Dear Pr Nathan Hepler, Pr Hachemi Benhassaini, Thank you for your reply. It is right that the monophyly of Spermatophytes was the most probable, I was confused since some studies did not recognize the seed as synapomorphy, However, the ovule is.
I find this paper, it is not the most recent, but it supports that all of spermatophytes, Gymnosperms and Angiosperms of course are monophyletic groups.
Article A Functional Phylogenomic View of the Seed Plants