Hi everyone,
I just wonder whether a literature review can be sufficient to get an article published on a peer-review journal? Some said to me that it would need to get primary data, some say that analysing secondary data can be enough with a strong argument.
Any advice would be very much appreciated.
Thank you.
Best,
kien
Dear Kien,
The answer to your question is YES. We can publish a systematic and critical review of literature on a particular field. You can find many articles in well-reputed journals that are only literature reviews.
Some examples are here:
Article Industrial maintenance decision-making: A systematic literature review
Article Authentication Schemes and Methods: a Systematic Literature Review
Article Burnout and Interventions in Pediatric Residency: A Literature Review
Article A Literature Review of Alternative Therapies for Postpartum Depression
Article Gamified Crowdsourcing: Conceptualization, Literature Review...
Article How to Develop Usability Heuristics: A Systematic Literature Review
Article A systematic literature review of research on diversity and ...
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0748575117300416
Article A literature review of mentorship programs in academic nursing
Article Life values of elderly people suffering from incurable cance...
Best Wishes,
Atif
Hi Kien.
The answer is yes - but it depends on a number of different factors. For instance, there are different types of 'literature reviews'. There is the 'standard' opinion-piece literature review - which used to be popular a decade or more ago - but is far less favourable nowadays. Literature reviews with more rigour are now favoured i.e. integrative reviews and systematic reviews. Systematic literature reviews are not to be confused with the likes of systematic reviews/meta-analysis that you would find in repositories such as the Cochrane Library - nor meta-synthesis of qualitative studies. From a qualitative research perspective, narrative reviews are a different form of review that are popular in some disciplines, such as nursing and midwifery, i.e. concept analysis and discourse analysis.
The best thing to do is to check if your targeted journals publish literature reviews and, if so, what format they might favour. There are many journals out there that will favour primary articles over secondary reviews.
The attached chapter may assist - especially towards the latter part.
Hi Trung-Kien.
You can convert your literature review to systemic review
The attached files may help you
Good luck
The simple answer is yes, but see whether you need primary data as well. I did the following article based on existing literature.
Article Globalisation and Construction of Local Culture in Rural Sri Lanka
Dear all, thank you very much for your advice and recommended documents. They are very helpful. I so much appreciate.
Best regards,
kien
Hi Trung Kien,
I agree with Mohamed A. Hammad.
Convert your literature review to systematic review is an excellent solution.
I have guidance from Udochisom Anaba may help you.
below I attach the file.
Dear Trung Kien,
A systematic literature review, as described by Dean can make a valid scientific contribution by assembling previously disparate data and enabling temporal trends and patterns to be perceived, even without primary data. However, having a sound methodology will certainly increase the chances of publication. I contributed to such a review, which audited herpes zoster research in the Asia-Pacific region, that may be an example for you.
https://bmcinfectdis.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12879-017-2198-y
Dear Kien,
The answer to your question is YES. We can publish a systematic and critical review of literature on a particular field. You can find many articles in well-reputed journals that are only literature reviews.
Some examples are here:
Article Industrial maintenance decision-making: A systematic literature review
Article Authentication Schemes and Methods: a Systematic Literature Review
Article Burnout and Interventions in Pediatric Residency: A Literature Review
Article A Literature Review of Alternative Therapies for Postpartum Depression
Article Gamified Crowdsourcing: Conceptualization, Literature Review...
Article How to Develop Usability Heuristics: A Systematic Literature Review
Article A systematic literature review of research on diversity and ...
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0748575117300416
Article A literature review of mentorship programs in academic nursing
Article Life values of elderly people suffering from incurable cance...
Best Wishes,
Atif
Yes, literature review articles are a type of research articles. You can see many articles published in good journals that are only literature reviews and meta analyses.
Yes, you may write a REVIEW ARTICLE based on the published work only, no need to add your own data/results. But it must be written for specific goal.
Although many replies already provided excellent reference sources, those relating to systematic reviews may seem daunting to a novice, and are not necessarily relevant to produce a publishable narrative literature review. I found some specific guidance on this topic very helpful: Article Writing Narrative Literature Reviews for Peer-Reviewed Journ...
Article Writing a narrative biomedical review: Considerations for au...
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Linguistics
- Composition Studies
- Publisher