You often find some mistakes on a published paper and you want to correct these mistakes. But some journals refuse to publish these corrigenda without paying fees. I think the journal is ethically committed to publish this type of papers, after check it, without asking fees from the authors.
What is view of you? and how we can deal with this type of journals?
Dr. @ Ahlam H. Tolba , hopefully that will be done
with regard to who correct the mistakes?
Any one discover these errors , authors or interested readers, can do amendments
They are essentially super predatory journals. Many journals do not pay head to such requests but I have never seen asking for money again!
I think that the payment for saying the truth should be forgotten and avoided because the truth has a value too which would not be effective never.
Prof. Subir Bandyopadhyay I agree with your description "it is essentially super predatory journals"
Prof. Mariano Ruiz Espejo
We need to differentiate between academic journals and financial journals.
some journals ask the authors to pay for publishing their original work and this it's right, however, when these journals publish papers containing errors, I think it is obligated to publish corundum papers without asking fees
To maintain the reputation of journal, I think it must accept any corundum paper after check it without asking fees. If these journals insist to ask authors charge and the authors refuse, what is the outcome?
The errors still and may be others do wrong conclusion depend on these errors
In the end, this leads to a lack of confidence in the publication of this journals
Yes
I think it is commitd to publish these type of papers without fee
We need to scientific organizations or corporation for obligating these journals to publish corrigenda paper without charge
We must try to change the policy of these journals in the handling of their published research, where when the payment for publication must be agreed upon in the case of post-publication of the papers if there are errors must be corrected by the authors to give everyone the right information and on these journals Publish the amendment to research without payment again.
Dr. @ Ahlam H. Tolba , hopefully that will be done
with regard to who correct the mistakes?
Any one discover these errors , authors or interested readers, can do amendments
Dr. @ Ahlam H. Tolba , hopefully that will be done
with regard to who correct the mistakes?
Any one discover these errors , authors or interested readers, can do amendments
Dr. @ Tareq Al-shami , the errors corrected by authors but i mean the journals after this corrections must be republish the paper without any fees. I am with you in your opinion any one discover these errors, authors or interested readers, can do adjustments. I hope that there will be a radical change in the politics of famous journals and accept opinions.
Dear Dr. Tareq
We should try to change this police of these journals and obligated them to publish correction papers without fees
Regards
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Linguistics
- Composition Studies
- Publisher