Are economic growth and environmental sustainability compatible and ecological sustainability in relation to the development process?
One theory of economic growth and the environment is that up to a certain point economic growth worsens the environment, but after that the move to a post-industrial economy it leads to a better environment. Sustainable development means “meeting the needs of the present generation without compromising the needs of future generations”. Thus, economic growth will be sustainable if fixed assets, including land, remain constant or increase over time. Sustainable development aims at promoting the kind of development that minimizes environmental problems and meets the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of the future generation to meet their own needs. The difference is that environmental economics studies the relationship between the environment and the economy, while ecological economics considers the economy to be a subsystem of the wider ecosystem. Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Economic development leads to economic growth. Growth happens through the changes brought about by development, as the quality of life can impact the output of products and services. The goal of economic development is economic growth. Economic growth and development indicate progress in a country's economy. Our ecosystem, the earth, ultimately controls our economic systems because it provides us with what we need for our economies to actually exist. As we must have water, food, and goods that we then buy, sell, or trade with others in order to profit economically.
I believe that environmental problems are insufficiently scientifically explained. I think that ideas come from the West that cannot be accepted as correct. I personally believe that the military industry is the main polluter of the environment. If you consider how many countries have nuclear weapons, how many trials there were before the final adoption of that type of weapon, you will see how much heat and various gases went into the atmosphere. A hypersonic rocket has an external temperature close to 2000 Celsius. How much is the atmosphere polluted through the testing of these and similar rockets? Also, consider how many wars have been fought since WWII. Tons and tons of bombs, rockets, millions of airstrikes were dropped... Bombs with radioactive uranium were dropped in Serbia. Petrochemical plants and the chemical industry were targeted. Mercury poured out... When scientists from the military industry answer these questions, only then should we seriously think about economic growth and environmental sustainability and ecological sustainability in relation to the development process.
Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Economic Development refers to the development of the economy in terms of financial progress, advancement in technology and improvement in standard of living. Sustainable Development means the use of available resources in such a manner that present and future generations can reap the benefits. Development that meets the needs of present generations while not compromising the ability of future generations to also meet their needs. Sustainable development practices help countries grow in ways that adapt to the challenges posed by climate change, which will in turn help to protect important natural resources for ours and future generations. By the year 2050, it is estimated that our global population will likely reach 9 billion people. Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” This implies that we need to look after our planet, our resources and our people to ensure that we can live in a sustainable manner.To reach ecological sustainability, the production of goods and services must not ruin ecosystems past their ability to function and recuperate. Water, air, land, biodiversity, and ecosystem services are all central to ecological sustainability. The global economy recycles less than 10 percent of materials; about 50 percent of processed materials are used to provide energy and are thus not available for recycling. It is simple: economic growth is not compatible with environmental sustainability. Environmental economics focuses on how they use and manage finite resources in a manner that serves the population while meeting concerns about environmental impact. This helps governments weigh the pros and cons of alternative measures and design appropriate environmental policies. Sustainable development means “meeting the needs of the present generation without compromising the needs of future generations”. Thus, economic growth will be sustainable if fixed assets, including land, remain constant or increase over time. Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Sustainable development aims at promoting the kind of development that minimizes environmental problems and meets the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of the future generation to meet their own needs. Sustainability focuses on equal economic growth, that generates wealth for all, without harming the environment. Investment and an equal distribution of the economic resources will strengthen the other pillars of sustainability for a complete development.
تهدف الاستدامة الاقتصادية إلى تحقيق النمو الاقتصادي بشكل يتيح استمرارية هذا النمو على المدى الطويل. يتعين أن يكون النمو الاقتصادي مستدامًا من حيث الاستفادة من الموارد بشكل فعال وتحسين جودة الحياة للأفراد والمجتمعات. يتطلب ذلك النمو الاقتصادي الاهتمام بقضايا مثل التكنولوجيا النظيفة والابتكار وتنمية المهارات البشرية.
Development that meets the needs of present generations while not compromising the ability of future generations to also meet their needs. All production and consumption must be ecologically sustainable and socio-economically equitable, using a mix of incentives and disincentives and all infrastructure development must be ecologically sustainable and socio-economically equitable.Sustainable development practices help countries grow in ways that adapt to the challenges posed by climate change, which will in turn help to protect important natural resources for ours and future generations. Avoiding the use of plastic bags to keep the oceans clean. Life on land: Planting trees to help protect the environment. Responsible consumption and production: Recycling items such as paper, plastic, glass and aluminum. Sustainable cities and communities: Biking, walking or using public transport. Renewable energy, such as solar, wind, hydroelectric, and biomass, are examples of sustainable practices. Sustainability in agriculture includes crop rotation, crop cover, and smart water usage, while sustainability in forestry involves selective logging and forest management. These traits are determined by a set of four "interactive controls" (climate, soil resource supply, major functional groups of organisms, and disturbance regime) that both govern and respond to ecosystem processes. Ecosystems cannot be sustained unless the interactive controls oscillate within stable bounds. The global economy recycles less than 10 percent of materials; about 50 percent of processed materials are used to provide energy and are thus not available for recycling. It is simple: economic growth is not compatible with environmental sustainability. Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Economic Development refers to the development of the economy in terms of financial progress, advancement in technology and improvement in standard of living. Sustainable Development means the use of available resources in such a manner that present and future generations can reap the benefits. Green growth means fostering economic growth and development while ensuring that natural assets continue to provide the resources and environmental services on which our well-being relies. One way to achieve this balance is through policy changes. Governments can implement regulations and incentives that prioritize environmental sustainability, such as incentives for renewable energy development and regulations to reduce pollution and protect natural habitats.
Yes. In general economic growth has a negative correlation with pollution, as competition and innovation drives both efficiency and more environmentally friendly processes.
There are of course examples of particular companies polluting their surroundings, but on a macro scale the relationship is propitious for the climate.
The most important factor then becomes increased trade with poor parts of the world, which happens through free trade agreements and strong market institutions.
There is tradeoff between economic growth and environment because of desire to high growth and excessive use of resources that cause environmental pollution. Poor people and poor countries depend on the soil for food, the rivers for water and forests for fuel. It is simple: economic growth is not compatible with environmental sustainability. The global economy recycles less than 10 percent of materials; about 50 percent of processed materials are used to provide energy and are thus not available for recycling. It is simple: economic growth is not compatible with environmental sustainability. Green growth means fostering economic growth and development while ensuring that natural assets continue to provide the resources and environmental services on which our well-being relies.Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Sustainable development means “meeting the needs of the present generation without compromising the needs of future generations”. Thus, economic growth will be sustainable if fixed assets, including land, remain constant or increase over time. Sustainable development means “meeting the needs of the present generation without compromising the needs of future generations”. Thus, economic growth will be sustainable if fixed assets, including land, remain constant or increase over time. Ecologically sustainable development involves attaining economic growth which allows for long-term preservation of the environment and natural resources, allowing for future generations to maintain access to resources. The benefits of Sustainable Economic Development impact more than just those in poverty. For example, reducing energy use and expanding public transit options leads to less air pollution, which can improve asthma and heart conditions. Efficient homes and businesses will be more comfortable and safer. Separately, environment is defined here as the entirety of the physical world consisting of the world's land masses, oceans, and atmosphere. Development is defined as the process of growth and change in human social, political, and economic systems. Economic development is often put ahead of environmental sustainability as it involves people's standards of living. However, quality of life can decline if people live in an economic place with a poor environmental quality because of economic development. Development is a common trend of each individual and the whole human being in the process of living. There is a very close relationship between environment and development: the environment is the locality and the object of development and development is the cause of environmental changes. The environment provides major raw materials for industries. Economy processes raw material to make finished goods. The environment provides industries with all the natural resources. The economy invests in developing technology to optimize the use of natural resources.
Before making a determination it would be necessary to properly define what you are measuring. if you measure growth or development by measures such as GDP it would be easy to see incompatibility. Clear cutting forests, building on marshlands, add to market measures of income and contribute to growth by such measures but these actions are not compatible with sustainable development. However, if the full values of those forests and marshlands, including their environmental benefits, are used then doing such things reduce the more proper measure of income and development while not doing them enhances both sustainability and income. At least some of the perceived tradeoffs between the two are artifacts of the failure of proper measurement,
Rana Hamza Shakil
provided a very good reply. I would also add that HOW we pay for public infrastructure (roads, water, sewer, electricity, transit, etc.) can help determine whether growth and sustainability are compatible or contradictory.For example, in many places, we charge user fees for water. They encourage conservation and motivates us to fix leaky faucets. If we paid for water with a sales tax on retail goods, there would be no such incentive for conservation.
Unfortunately, in the USA, both roadways and parking are underpriced. This leads to excessive driving, congestion and pollution which can be contrary to both growth and sustainability.
In the USA, the traditional property tax encourages land speculation. This inflates land prices at prime sites and induces sprawl development that is bad for both the environment and for taxpayers due to the duplication of expensive infrastructure systems in low-density areas. However, some communities have remedied this by reducing the tax rate applied to privately created building values while increasing the tax rate applied to publicly-created land values. Without any new spending or loss of revenue, this "TAX SHIFT" creates incentives for more affordable and compact development patters, reducing sprawl.
So, as others have said, the answers to this question are complex. They are also influenced by how we define "growth" and "sustainability" and by the metrics we use to measure them. And, as I indicated above, we can manage both growth and sustainability through our choices of taxes and fees. Some contain incentives for sustainability and growth and some are contrary.
For more information about the "tax shift" see https://www.shareable.net/land-value-return-and-building-a-more-equitable-economy/
(1) Economic Growth and Environmental Sustainability as well as Ecological Sustainability are compatible in the development process. The Problem is is and has always been Politics, Politics, Politics!!! Getting in the way!!
(2) Currently we may still be experiencing some tradeoffs but in the long run with Governments supporting Heavy Investments in New Technological Advancements, we shall minimize the requisite Tradeoffs between Economic Growth and Environmental and Ecological Sustainability.
(3) Example One we have Shipping and Air transportation of Merchandize and Services across the Globe from one country to another country (Read International Trade) which obviously is among the stimulants of Economic Growth.
(4) The Shipping and Air Transport are pollutants of the environment using Petrochemical Fuels. But there are efforts to improve the Technology of generating alternative fuels or their Hybrids with Lower Carbon Foot Prints such as: (a) Bio-DIESEL from Food Wastes and Plant Biomass that is not necessarily in direct line of causing Food Insecurity such as Candlenut Trees Nuts. Biodiesels from Vegetable and Animal Fats and Oils have Higher Cetane Numbers and Higher Lubricities than Petroleum Diesel used in Shipping Transport. We need to improve the Technology and Business Models to eventually make enough Biodiesel for mixing with Petroleum Diesel to reduce the Shipping Transport Carbon Foot Print. (b) Bio-ETHANOL produced from Lignocellulosic Biomass (such as sugarcane and sweet sorghum bagasse) can be blended with conventional Jet Fuels by up to 50 Percent without any Modifications. Use of Bio-Ethanol as a mixture with ordinary Jet Fuels can reduce GHG Emissions by 80 Percent.
(5) There are many renewable Energy sources with Low Carbon and Methane Foot Prints whose technology can be improved to make them cheaper and more abundant for use by Heavy Industries and Consumers while in the quest for rapid economic growth. We have Methane that can be produced and channeled to Bio-Liquified Gas for heating or used to produce electricity. We need to improve the technology to source it from Landfills, Animal Manure, Lakes and Wetlands, etc. We have Windmill technology Completely Under-developed in Africa. The same with Geothermal technology.
(6) Politics keeps getting in the way of Developing and Upgrading Circular Value Chains in many industrial sectors in developed and developing countries. Economic Growth can be compatible with Environmental Sustainability if we make sacrifices to begin adapting and modifying many enterprises' value chains to Circular Value Chains where the technology allows us and the Costs allow us. Recycling materials whenever the Costs and Technology allow us is one way forward to show that Econ Growth and Environmental Sustainability can exist with Minimized Tradeoffs.
Green growth means fostering economic growth and development while ensuring that natural assets continue to provide the resources and environmental services on which our well-being relies. Economic Development refers to the development of the economy in terms of financial progress, advancement in technology and improvement in standard of living. Sustainable Development means the use of available resources in such a manner that present and future generations can reap the benefits. Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Environmental problems and their solution in Economies: With the help of input-output analysis, cost benefit analysis, pollution tax and environmental subsidies, economics shows various ways and means to solve the environmental problems. Environmental problems are basically man-made and economics has solution for them. Reducing land usage and making supply chains more efficient with less resources required to operate or maintain them. Reducing harmful emissions and pollutants in every stage of the business and balance economic growth and opportunities with less environmental impact. Economic development is often put ahead of environmental sustainability as it involves people's standards of living. However, quality of life can decline if people live in an economic place with a poor environmental quality because of economic development. Development that meets the needs of present generations while not compromising the ability of future generations to also meet their needs. Avoiding the use of plastic bags to keep the oceans clean. Life on land: Planting trees to help protect the environment. Responsible consumption and production: Recycling items such as paper, plastic, glass and aluminum. Sustainable cities and communities. Sustainable development is the pattern of resource use that goals to meet human needs along with preserving the environment so that needs can be met not only in the present but also for upcoming generations.
The influence of ecological sustainability on economic growth is a complex and multifaceted topic. Some studies suggest that nature-positive transitions and circular economy practices can generate significant value and jobs for the global economy. Other studies argue that economic growth can also improve the environment after a certain point, as it provides the resources and awareness for sustainability. However, the relationship between sustainability and growth may vary depending on the sector, the region, and the level of development.
In summary, there is no clear answer to whether economic growth is compatible with or contrary to sustainable economics. It depends on various factors such as the level of development of a country and its policies.
Economic growth is when the gross domestic product (GDP) increases over a period of time. Sustainable growth means maintaining the growth rate without causing other economic problems. Rapid growth may deplete resources, create environmental problems and contribute to global warming. The global economy recycles less than 10 percent of materials; about 50 percent of processed materials are used to provide energy and are thus not available for recycling. It is simple: economic growth is not compatible with environmental sustainability. With the economic sustainability ecological system is maintained and all the environmental terms are kept in balance. Natural resources are consumed by humans, taking care that they are preserved, for future generations. Sustainability is all about keeping these three pillars in balance. The natural environment is central to economic activity and growth, providing the resources we need to produce goods and services, and absorbing and processing unwanted by-products in the form of pollution and waste. Economic policies such as rationalization of price subsidies, the clarification of property rights, and facilitation of technology transfer may help in achieving environmental sustainability. Economic growth is closely linked to increasing production, consumption and resource use, which has negative effects on nature, climate and human health. Moreover, current research suggests that it is unlikely that economic growth can be completely detached from its environmental impacts. Economic development is often put ahead of environmental sustainability as it involves people's standards of living. However, quality of life can decline if people live in an economic place with a poor environmental quality because of economic development. Development that meets the needs of present generations while not compromising the ability of future generations to also meet their needs. Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” This implies that we need to look after our planet, our resources and our people to ensure that we can live in a sustainable manner. Sustainable development practices help countries grow in ways that adapt to the challenges posed by climate change, which will in turn help to protect important natural resources for ours and future generations.
There is a correlation between the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration and temperature change. As the concentration of carbon dioxide has increased, the global average temperature has generally increased too. The Earth’s average temperature has gradually increased over time
The relationship between CO2 concentration level and global change in temperature is complex and multifaceted. However, there is a strong scientific consensus that human activities, such as burning fossil fuels, have contributed significantly to the increase in atmospheric CO2 concentrations and global warming
Hello Dr. Arize. You are right in your observation that strong scientific evidence shows that human activities, such as burning fossil fuels, have had a large contribution to increased atmospheric CO2 concentrations and global warming. Politics aside, economic growth can take place with reduced environmental degradation or pollution. This can only happen if there is strong Political Will to heavily Invest in Technologies that reduce this pollution.
An example is sacrificing by opting to channel Heavy Investments in Green-oriented R&D and Marketing Programs. Look at the case of Electric Vehicles and improving on their Suitability and Costs to consumers. Economic Growth is coupled to Transportation (including Cars) so we cannot run away from Car Transportation. Toyota already has Proof of Concept of developing Car Batteries Last Longer during driving and Take Half the Time to Recharge for EVs. If heavy investments in the R&D and later the Marketing of these Batteries is done, and the Size of the Batteries becomes Smaller, then we can talk of seeing some light at the end of tunnel for Petrol and Diesel Cars while Econ Growth continues. Heavy Green investments in R&D of Reusing or Recycling the used Batteries can also allow reduced tradeoffs between Econ Growth and Environmental Conservation.
How about heavy Green investments in R&D and Marketing of the use of Agricultural Waste to make Bio-Diesel and Ethanol which can be blended with Fossil Diesel and Petrol to reduce dependence on Petrochemical fuels?? This is being done at a Very Small Scale but hopefully with increased Political Will, more investments will be done to improve the Technology and Reduce the Costs of Production of Biofuels at Scale. All this shows that Econ Growth can only Co-exist with Minimized Environmental Degradation if and only if Heavy Green Investments are also being done concurrently.
Sustainable development practices help countries grow in ways that adapt to the challenges posed by climate change, which will in turn help to protect important natural resources for ours and future generations. Development that meets the needs of present generations while not compromising the ability of future generations to also meet their needs. Amongst other things, this includes the stability of climate systems, the quality of air, land and water, land use and soil erosion, biodiversity, and ecosystem services. These topics include environmental impact assessment, monitoring and research, environmental literacy, and sustainability. All of these are necessary for maintaining an acceptable level of environmental quality and healthy ecosystems two necessary objectives for a truly sustainable socio-economic system. Economic growth will be undermined without adequate environmental safeguards, and environmental protection will fail without economic growth. The earth's natural resources place limits on economic growth. These limits vary with the extent of resource substitution, technical progress, and structural changes. Economic growth is when the gross domestic product (GDP) increases over a period of time. Sustainable growth means maintaining the growth rate without causing other economic problems. Rapid growth may deplete resources, create environmental problems and contribute to global warming. Environmental problems and their solution in Economies: With the help of input-output analysis, cost benefit analysis, pollution tax and environmental subsidies, economics shows various ways and means to solve the environmental problems. Environmental problems are basically man-made and economics has solution for them.
تطوّر الاهتمام بموضوع التنمية في العقود الماضية بطريقةٍ نقلته من حيّز الدراسات الاقتصادية والاجتماعية إلى الفضاء السياسي والموضوع البيئي أيضًا، وأعطي الاعتبار لمحورية الإنسان والموارد الطبيعية في المنظور التنموي لتأمين حياةٍ كريمة وتوسيع حرّياته بصورةٍ دائمة. وفي السعي قدر الإمكان إلى تحقيق هذه الشمولية في رؤية مجالات التنمية، بين المؤثّرات السياسية والأداء الاقتصادي المرتبط بالأداء الإداري والمؤسساتي، كذلك بين المجتمع المدني والتنمية، وبين السياسة الإقليمية والسياسة المحلّية، وبين الامن التنموي والانساني والسياسة العالمية هنا بالضبط يستدعي التعايش بين الاقتصاد والسياسة والبيئة من جهة والدول الغنية والفقيرة من جهة اخرى للوصول الى بناء مقاربة تنموية مستدامة
key considerations:
1. Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): The United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals recognize the interdependence between economic growth, environmental sustainability, and social progress. The goals aim to strike a balance by addressing poverty eradication, social inclusion, and environmental protection simultaneously.
2. Decoupling Economic Growth from Resource Consumption: One approach is to decouple economic growth from the excessive consumption of finite resources and environmental degradation. This can be achieved through technological innovation, resource efficiency, and the adoption of cleaner production processes. By promoting circular economy principles, such as recycling, reusing, and reducing waste, economic growth can be achieved with less impact on the environment.
3. Green Technologies and Renewable Energy: Embracing and promoting green technologies and renewable energy sources can contribute to both economic growth and environmental sustainability. Investments in renewable energy infrastructure, energy-efficient technologies, and sustainable transportation systems can stimulate economic activity while reducing greenhouse gas emissions and dependence on fossil fuels.
4. Sustainable Resource Management: Effective management of natural resources is crucial for long-term sustainability. This involves practices such as sustainable forestry, responsible water management, and sustainable agriculture. By ensuring the responsible use and conservation of resources, economic growth can be pursued without depleting or damaging the ecosystems on which it depends.
5. Conservation and Biodiversity Protection: Preserving biodiversity and protecting ecosystems are essential for ecological sustainability. Encouraging conservation efforts, establishing protected areas, and implementing sustainable land-use practices are important steps towards maintaining ecosystem services and supporting long-term economic development.
6. Policy and Governance: Sound environmental policies, regulations, and governance frameworks play a vital role in reconciling economic growth with environmental sustainability. Governments can implement measures such as environmental impact assessments, pollution control regulations, and incentives for sustainable practices to ensure that economic activities align with environmental goals.
7. Stakeholder Engagement and Collaboration: Achieving a balance between economic growth and environmental sustainability requires collaboration among various stakeholders, including governments, businesses, communities, and civil society organizations. Engaging stakeholders in decision-making processes, promoting dialogue, and fostering partnerships can lead to more sustainable development outcomes.
It is possible to pursue economic development while safeguarding the environment and promoting ecological sustainability.
Good luck!!
State-of-the-art sustainability practices can transform traditional economic development and poverty alleviation strategies. Creating resource efficiencies in areas such as water, transportation, energy, and material use makes communities more equitable and resilient while lowering the cost of living. Economic growth is when the gross domestic product (GDP) increases over a period of time. Sustainable growth means maintaining the growth rate without causing other economic problems. Rapid growth may deplete resources, create environmental problems and contribute to global warming.With the conservation of all the energy and natural resources, environmental sustainability can be attained. With the economic sustainability ecological system is maintained and all the environmental terms are kept in balance. With the conservation of all the energy and natural resources, environmental sustainability can be attained. With the economic sustainability ecological system is maintained and all the environmental terms are kept in balance. A switch from fossil fuel-based to low-carbon energy sources can help sustain the same or even higher levels of production while reducing emissions, thereby enabling the decoupling of growth from emissions. One distinction that may be made between environmental and ecological economics is the notion of "value": environmental economists tend to focus on human preferences, while ecological economists tend to focus on the science and environmental consequences of economic decisions. Sustainable development can be applied to corporate policy in the business world as it encompasses three key areas: economic, environmental and social. Sustainable development requires that a company must contribute to economic growth, social progress and promote environmental sustainability.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Human-Computer Interaction
- Collaboration