We are performing MOKE experiments in polar and longitudinal geometries. Our samples range from single magnetron-sputtered or electrodeposited magnetic metals to multilayers. We use a PEM and lock-in amplifier in the standard configuration. Most of the time, we get MOKE signals that are shaped liked a butterfly. See attached. This means, reversing the field does not invert the signal. Sometimes, however, the desired inversion does take place.
Are we not properly understanding the lock-in phase, or is the magnetization not really reversing its alignment, or is there something more subtle behind all this?