Hi all,
could you please help choosing the best RT simulator for electrical engineering research.
We are confused between the OPAL (op4510) or RTDS ?
it should have the ability to simulate a complete electrical power system (Microgrids) including generators, transmission lines, PV, wind turbines, relays, arrestors, batteries, super capacitors,....
besides, it will be used in real time control for different electric motors
the easier the programming the best.
thanks in advance
You could locate some users of these software tools and take their opinion. The companies may be able to direct you to universities that are using the tools.
There are currently many simulators in electronics that are very good. But each simulator is to some extent aimed at a specific type of electronic device. There are also more universal simulators, but in most cases they are for amateur purposes. I think that in order to get good advice from colleagues here, you need to specify for what type of electronic devices you will use it.
I have found both systems very capable for Hardware in the loop simulation. RTDS seems to be more used in the power industry. At institutions where Matlab is a predominate tool, Opal often gets used due to the interface with Matlab. From the users perspective, If you typically use EMTPRV you will find Opal's Hypersim very similar and intuitive. If you like PSCAD for offline simulation then you will find RTDS's RSCAD very intuitive.
Thank you very much for your answers.
it is really helpful and appreciated.
Aaron Findley , Zeashan H. Khan , Anton Georgiev , and C.P. Ravikumar
Both the OP4510 and RTDS are real-time simulators that can be used for electrical engineering research. However, they have different strengths and weaknesses.
The OP4510 is a smaller, more affordable simulator that is well-suited for individual users or small groups. It is easy to use and has a wide range of features, including support for multiple power systems, communication networks, and control systems.
The RTDS is a larger, more expensive simulator that is designed for use by research teams or universities. It is more powerful than the OP4510 and can be used to simulate larger and more complex power systems. However, it is also more difficult to use and requires more training.
Ultimately, the best real-time simulator for electrical engineering research depends on the specific needs of the user or team. If you are looking for an affordable, easy-to-use simulator for individual use, the OP4510 is a good option. If you need a more powerful simulator for use by a research team or university, the RTDS is a better choice. Here are some additional factors to consider when choosing a real-time simulator:
- The size and complexity of the power system you want to simulate. The OP4510 is limited in its ability to simulate large and complex power systems. If you need to simulate a large power system, the RTDS is a better choice.
- The features you need. The OP4510 has a wide range of features, but it does not support all features. If you need a specific feature, make sure the simulator you choose supports it.
- The training required. The OP4510 is easy to use and does not require any training. The RTDS is more difficult to use and requires training. If you do not have the time or resources to train on the RTDS, the OP4510 is a better choice.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Counseling Psychology
- Confusion