11 November 2013 10 9K Report

Imagine a block of wood resting on two supports at each end. You point a gun upward under the block and shoot the block upwards.

One scenario is you shoot the block upwards in the exact center. Another scenario is you shoot upwards near one of the support ends. The block is thick enough that in both cases the bullet comes to rest inside the block.

Question: in which case does the centre of mass of the block rise the highest?

Doing this problem shows you that you get a different answer if you use conservation of energy vs. conservation of momentum.

Main question: when teaching students dynamics is there a prescription you can give them to make it clear when and when not to use conservation of energy?

This example shows you that conservation of momentum applies, but there is not enough information in the question to successfully use conservation of energy (because you don't know how much the bullet heats up the block). Are there problems where conservation of energy works, but conservation of momentum becomes a problem? Or is it always the other way around? Why?

More Derek Abbott's questions See All
Similar questions and discussions