Mantle plumes

Sudip:

Experts believe that the rapidly moving Indian subcontinent over the Reunion hotspot resulted in vast outpouring of lava stretching from western to eastern India producing Large Igneous Province (LIP) of Deccan fllood Basalt (ca. 66 Ma ago).

Kindly refrain from taking harbourage in a false propaganda that Deccan volcanism induced environmental change was responsible for the most spectacular Mass Extinction and the demise of not only Indian but global dinosaurs. Good thoughts and sound reasoning would help us inch towards the truth.

Best

Syed

Greetings. I completely agree with Dr.Syed Jafar suggestion .

Regards to all

Following. I would like to thank all for their valuable comments. It really helped and inspired me.

Sudip:

Be advised to look at my comments in papers of Jahnvi Punekar and Gerta Keller at ResearcgGate on similar themes.

Best

Syed

Environmental changes during the Cretaceous-Paleogene mass extinction and Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum: Implications for the Anthropocene

• December 2017
• Gondwana Research 56
• DOI:
• 10.1016/j.gr.2017.12.002
• 📷Gerta Keller
• 📷Paula Mateo
• 📷Jahnavi Punekar
• Show all 8 authors
• 📷Thierry Adatte

Citations📷📷📷6Recommendations📷📷📷0 new3Reads5 new746See detailsOverviewStatsComments (1)Citations (6)References (122)Related research (10+)DownloadRecommendRecommend this workFollowingGet updatesShareShare in a messageStart a discussionDiscuss this article with your peersComments (1)📷Sep 23, 2018Syed Abbas Jafaradded a commentDear Authors:“In question of science, the authority of a thousand is not worth the humble reasoning of a single individual” Galileo GalileiYour recent papers: Punekar et al. (2015). A multiproxy approach..etc. and this paper attracted my attention, obviously for the meticulously worked out sections and fanciful graphic depiction of valuable data of precision and fine stratigraphic resolution from K-Pg boundary. But unfortunately, both the papers lack a plausible hypothesis which could withstand the criticism. The social media and speed at which such inadequately ripe matters are published and spread makes such ideas injurious to the upcoming younger geoscientists. In my humble opinion, this can be branded, as psychologists say: “The Hasty Generalization Fallacy and The Correlation/Causation Fallacy.”It must be firmly registered that Catastrophism, like Extraterrestrial Impact on planet earth or episodes of Large Igneous Provinces like Deccan Flood Basalt can never cause biotic turnovers (extinction and origination of species) including Mass Extinctions either directly or indirectly by inducing global climatic deterioration, affecting shallow to deep sea, low to high latitude terrestrial fauna and flora. Only local damage can be allowed at the site of Catastrophism. The sensational publication of a Father-Son duo (Alvarez et al.1980) nearly four decades ago claiming that Impact hypothesis is responsible for K-Pg boundary and perhaps other four Mass extinction

Dear Sir Dr. Syed A. Jafar,

Good afternoon. I very pleased to thank you for sharing your views, ideas and knowledge with me. I agree with you.

Sincerely yours

Sudip