Hi ! I composed an article regarding Spine surgeries and submitted it to the journal of clinical neuroscience. Although the article was well-written with strong references, it was still rejected. As it was a critique letter to the editor, and the parent article was in the journal of clinical neuroscience, the author guidelines suggest that it can't be submitted to another journal. The editor sent a list of transfer journals where I can submit my manuscript, and get it published. The journal I chose is World neurosurgery. My query is that as the etter crituiqes on the parent article of another journal, can I slightly reframe it into a commentary or review and then submit it? Please share insights. It would prove to be helpful. Regards!
Dear Mariam Fatima
Indeed the transfer from a parent to a sister journal is a service provide by a substantial number of journals. See for a little bit of background on this https://mclibrary.duke.edu/news/publishing-sister-journals#:~:text=For%20you%2C%20as%20the%20submitting,process%20at%20the%20second%20journal.
As indicated here, do realize that in most cases the sister journal is an open acces journal. The same is true for “World Neurosurgery”, do note that the APC is ‘substantial’ (3200 USD) https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/world-neurosurgery/publish/open-access-options
The journal offers a waiver in some cases
https://www.elsevier.com/researcher/author/open-access/choice like the so-called Research4life https://www.research4life.org/access/eligibility/ Still this means an APC of 1600 USD.
If you nevertheless want to proceed then I estimate that adjusting your work into a commentary might be the best way to proceed.
Best regards.
Its a common part of the academic journey. Read through the feedback provided by the reviewers and editor as hey often contain helpful insights that can guide you in improving your manuscript.
Consider whether the rejection was due to the content itself or simply a mismatch with the journal’s scope. If the former, revise your work thoroughly—addressing any weak points, clarifying your argument, and ensuring your methods and conclusions are clearly presented. If the latter, look for a journal that better aligns with your topic and approach. Seek feedback from trusted colleagues if needed, and when you’re ready, submit your improved manuscript elsewhere.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Computer Science
- Research Topics